I've liked you from the start, I'll admit it now
That just ain't how you play
You set me up with your girlfriends
Leave it all behind, all the baggage and dreams
You set me up with your girlfriends

There's no way to convince you girls
It's hard to look at me
There's no way to convince you girls
Girl, I gotta have you
Singin' along to the words you don't know
I'm startin' to realize lately
What I do, think or say
What I do or think or say
I should've been after you

I should've been after you
But none of them worked out for me

I could've been after you
You're drivin' around town, blastin' your mixes
Run along with your new boy
I should've been after you
I should've been after you
But none of them worked out for me
That just ain't how you play, no
'Cause you're the only one who understands

But that's what you get when you live in a small world
But it makes no difference
I can tell by your shakin' hands that you want me
You set me up with your girlfriends
But after last night we're through

So baby, don't hold back, go with the flow
Forgive me and let me in

I know it looks bad 'cause I kissed all your girlfriends
Hope he's sex toy
But none of them worked out for me

Forget, it makes things easier

I'm startin' to realize lately
You need another man
I know you feel it too
You're wastin' all your time with someone else
When you know where my lips have been

You're gonna have to choose, is it me or them?
That's the way it goes
We don't have to tell anyone about our little secret
I should've been after you
But it makes no difference

I'm startin' to realize lately
I could've been after you