"[wednesday] night in the kingdom of doom..."

Posted about 5 years ago
One reason I'm none too fond of music reviews as a general rule: Every now and then professional music reviewers seem to collide and collude against a specific musician for no obvious reason. Like, say, Tim Kinsella. Every time I read a Joan of Arc or Make Believe review, I can actually visualize some smarmy 22-year-old Pitchfork-sired music critic crouching behind Tim while another, perhaps a writer for Tiny Mix Tapes, pushes him. Then maybe they kick him in the face for complaining. The party line is that Mr. Kinsella is "pretentious", an argument which seems to imply that most other musicians aren't.Similarly, Damon Albarn always seems to be under fire. According to the press, he's "tempermental", a "vicious drunk", a "control freak", "self-important", a "celebrity complaining about celebrity", a wannabe. 2003's one-off Democrazy, a 5,000-run 10" vinyl released on his own independent, was the proverbial whipping boy that year, more or less existing for reviewers to crack their knuckles and accuse the man of being "completely self-indulgent". [Interestingly, similar projects such as The Microphones' Little Bird Flies Into Big Black Cloud - a 300-run on a boutique label - and Fugazi's Instrument, which was basically the same thing as Democrazy only mass-produced, were roundly lauded (if they were reviewed at all, in the case of the former).] Even the reviews of The Good, the Bad, and the Queen - tied with Person Pitch as the year's best album so far, in my opinion - that praise the album tend to either express surprise at just how good it is or play down the contributions of the other members, refusing to let the reader forget for a moment that this is a "weird" album by a Complicated, Wary Former Brit-Pop Idol. Albarn's cranky, narcissistic public persona was created by music journalists and will be perpetuated by the same.Which bums me out, because I personally think Damon Albarn is one of the better songwriters we have at the moment. Blur's 13 and The Good, the Bad, and the Queen's self-titled debut are inventive, meticulously-crafted modern classics."Just my thoughts, man. Just some things I was thinkin' about at the time." - Jay-Z

Comments (1)

  1. Lester Jonze says I think maybe sometimes the reviewers are either jealous of the talent or the privilege artists get because of said talent. Or they get mad at the artist because the music they are putting out isn't what the reviewer wanted to see from their own standpoint as a fan. I stopped listening to what most reviewers said in the late eighties or early nineties, thanks to _Rolling Stone_ magazine. It also kind of inspired me to write reviews myself, cause if some of those hacks can pull it off...
    Permalink posted 04/18/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved