WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

Allison Moorer - Mockingbird

Posted about 1 year ago
In aesthetic practice and appreciation my decided preference has always been for the artisan as opposed to the virtuoso, for the lyric or meditative as opposed to the dramatic or rhetorical. So with, for example, an art form like opera, although there are musical passages and arias that are lyrical and beautiful, essentially it is a dramatic art and its stars are virtuosi not craftsmen. While the virtuosi in their performance say to us "Look at me doing this incredibly difficult thing incredibly well," the craftsmen's goal is to make the work look effortless as if anyone could do it, that and to make themselves disappear: "It's not about me," the artisan says, "It's about the flawless work."

I think these two poles: lyricism and drama, virtuosity and craft offer a context and a continuum for approaching the cover album. While I've only encountered the work of Cat Power in fleeting glances, and while with the occasional song she steps aside enough to let some other thing come forth and so enraptures me, for the most part the songs on Jukebox struck me as theatrical, as if with each song she were taking on a new role which quickly put me off, quite literally by keeping me at a distance, when I like my music close, intimate and immediate.

Paradoxically, sometimes at least, it is in the act of holding back rather than holding forth that an artist allows / enables her audience to come close. Receptivity invites me in; while self-presentation, the artist coming out to meet me and usher me in causes an instinctive step back. Listening to Allison Moorer's new cd the experience seems to be all about absorption: Moorer absorbing the work of other songwriters and absorbing the listener in the life of each song, so that what you get is not Allison Moorer or Patti Smith or Nina Simone or Joni Mitchell or June Carter Cash or Gillian Welch, but the pure, unadulturated song.

I think this is the point Moorer is making in the album's title song, the only song she wrote and the opener of the album: the mockingbird sings the songs of other birds, but still that borrowed music is no less the mockingbird's song. If the nightingale is an emblem of the virtuosic, the mockingbird is an apt emblem for the artisanly.

Probably it is a sign of some grave moral failing in me that I have yet to come to an appreciation of, let alone a reverence for, Patti Smith, which makes me all the more grateful to Allison Moorer for giving me this amazing Smith song in a form I can delight in.

And for good measure a cover by Simple Minds...

Comments (6)

  1. runobodyii says Dancing Barefoot
    -Patti Smith

    she is benediction she is addicted to thee she is the root connection she is connecting with he here I go and I don't know why I fell so ceaselessly could it be he's taking over me... I'm dancing barefoot heading for a spin some strange music draws me in makes me come on like some heroin/e she is sublimation she is the essence of thee she is concentrating on he, who is chosen by she here I go and I don't know why I spin so ceaselessly, could it be he's taking over me... [chorus] she is re-creation she, intoxicated by thee she has the slow sensation that he is levitating with she ... here I go and I don't know why, I spin so ceaselessly, 'til I lose my sense of gravity... [chorus] (oh god I fell for you ...) the plot of our life sweats in the dark like a face the mystery of childbirth, of childhood itself grave visitations what is it that calls to us? why must we pray screaming? why must not death be redefined? we shut our eyes we stretch out our arms and whirl on a pane of glass an afixiation a fix on anything the line of life the limb of a tree the hands of he and the promise that s/he is blessed among women. (oh god I fell for you ...)

    Permalink posted 03/09/2008
  2. funoka says Interesting post. I was going to post this song too, but got busy this week and didn't get around to it. I wondered what other might think about this version. I think the original is even more sinister and foreboding than this version by Allison. It is an interesting song for Allison to cover when you consider the herion-addiction problems of her husband, Steve Earle. I saw Steve perform a solo show in the mid-90s, when he was really bad off, and it wasn't pretty. Thank god, Steve kicked it and is still with us. Patti Smith can be a bit of "mockingbird" herself. She kind helped me get into the NYC punk thing back in the day with this song. And her cover of "Because the Night" got airplay before people in middle America even knew who Bruce Springsteen was. Springsteen didn't really hit where I grew up until "Darkness."
    Permalink posted 03/10/2008
  3. runobodyii says Yeah, I'm glad Earle decided to stick around too. I guess I just wish Smith would just try to sing. I'm just a philistine that way, imagine art has something to dy with beauty. Glad you're listening. Were you disappointed with Moorer's previous release Getting Somewhere? That seemed to be the consensus on her MOG artist's page, but I kinda liked it when I heard it for the first time on Saturday, but then, I'm coming to Moorer through the track "Mockingbird" which blew me away when I heard it on the Paste music sampler.
    Permalink posted 03/10/2008
  4. funoka says I like Patti's studio version of Dancing Barefoot much better than the liver version. On Allison's most recent releases, I think a lot people expect her to put out another masterpiece like "The Hardest Part." I'll take what I can get from her -- I'm just glad she's still in the music business after leaving MCA Nashville.
    Permalink posted 03/10/2008
  5. yrralmallik says Enjoyed Allsison's Take.Your Mog Bro.~(;Yrral Mallik;)
    Permalink posted 03/10/2008
  6. scotfree says There are plusses and minuses hear for me. On one hand, it is very true to the original - instrumentation up. I totally get what you suggest about artisan vs virtuoso, and I agree that this is accomplished - to the point that you almost forget it is a cover or even consider who is singing. Until, that is, Allison decides to change the phrasing on the few lines she does. Kind of blew it for me, but a really well written post. Enjoyed this mucho!!
    Permalink posted 03/10/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved