WE DO THE MASHED POTATO AND THE FUNKY CHICKEN

Holden meets Beck, Trey, Tom, Paul, and Sade

Posted over 2 years ago
I would like to take some time away from obsessing about My Morning Jacket (they are blowing my mind!) and focus on some cool action going on in my classroom this week. If you were like me in middle school, you were only interested in English, Gym, Break, and Lunch. My English teachers were damn good, and now I try to inspire and encourage my own students to read read read and write as much as possible.This week holds my favorite lesson plan: Analyzing Music Lyrics. The kiddies have just completed +Catcher in the Rye+ (have any of you read +King Dork+?) and instead of handing them a test, or assigning an essay, which they are given for almost every other book we read, we are analyzing lyrics and comparing them to the themes, characters, motifs, symbols, and tone in the story.Here are the songs that I use (click the title to check out the lyrics):"Waste":http://www.lyricsondemand.com/p/phishlyrics/wastelyrics.html by Phish"Guess I'm Doing Fine":http://www.lyricsondemand.com/b/becklyrics/guessimdoingfinelyrics.html by Beck"King of Sorrow":http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/sade/kingofsorrow.html by Sade"Fumblin' with the Blues":http://www.officialtomwaits.com/music/m_hsn_ly.htm#Fumblin_With_Blues by Tom Waits"I Am a Rock":http://www.lyricsfreak.com/s/simon+and+garfunkel/i+am+a+rock_20124809.html by Simon and GarfunkelWhen 14 year old kids-future leaders of this world-can find a deeper understanding of books, of themselves, of the world through music, it is a good day for everyone.

Comments (25)

  1. Joxley says Wow that's a really great idea. When I read _Catcher_ I had to write an essay on it and I ended up comparing it with musicians and lyrics.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  2. JCTrojan says Holden Caufield would've liked that idea
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  3. SatisfiedMind614 says You are allowed to teach A Catcher In The Rye? Too cool...here in the midwest we had to find Holden Caulfield on or own! Cool stuff happening in your class...i love it!!
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  4. Truth says Can I audit your class this week?
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  5. Cody B says What you are doing is awsome! Thank you Kids don't seem to get enough books and music these days. It sure as hell was a big part of my education in and out of school. Gets the brain working. I have just released my 5 year old into the school system here in Brooklyn and I do have my issues with the test prep guided curriculum, but the teachers are great. I just hope the need to prep for tests doesn't suck all the creativity out of them.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  6. extraordinarypoems says Sounds great! Maybe I will use some of the same songs in my classes! This semester I am using "This Land is Your Land," by Woody Guthrie, "God Bless the Child," by Billie Holiday and Arthur Herzog, Jr., and "Born in the U.S.A, by Bruce Springsteen, among others. "Born in the USA" Born down in a dead man's town The first kick I took was when I hit the ground You end up like a dog that's been beat too much Till you spend half your life just covering up Born in the USA I was born in the USA I was born in the USA Born in the USA Got in a little hometown jam So they put a rifle in my hand Sent me off to a foreign land To go and kill the yellow man Chorus Come back home to the refinery Hiring man says , "Son if it was up to me," Went down to see my V.A. man He said, "Son, don't you understand," I had a brother at the Khe Sanh fighting off the Viet Cong They're still there, he's all gone He had a woman he loved in Saigon I got a picture of him in her arms now Down in the shadow of the penitentiary Out by the gas fires of the refinery I'm ten years burning down the road Nowhere to run ain't go nowhere to go Chorus I'm a long gone Daddy in the U.S.A. I'm a cool rocking Daddy in the U.S.A.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  7. Daviso says I Am a Rock by Simon and Garfunkel is a great seque into other high-school level poems that i remember Mr Barner doing in English , especially after reading the Great Gatsby and Lord of the flies it was nice break. I would add a Clash or Bob Marly song just so the young leftist are represented... :-)
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  8. Wozniak says I never read this book. I tutored refugee kids reading it, but never read it myself.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  9. kb says Hey, thanks everyone! Daviso: I use Bob Marley, Peter Tosh, Ani DiFranco, and more when we read our next book, Mathabane's +Kaffir Boy+. Need to find a space for The Clash, though...hmmm. Wozniak: read it!
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  10. Joxley says You should check it out Shawn, you'll either love it or hate it, but either way you'll find it provocative. and I think there is something wrong with my eyes, the first time I looked I thought you said "I _tortured_ refugee kids reading it"
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  11. kb says lol, joxley, i thought the same thing, but knew it had to be wrong cause our boy woz is not that way.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  12. chucky says That's pretty awesome. You sound like a great teacher - your kids are getting challenged but they probably don't even realize it because your style is so refreshing.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  13. Anna says fn, this is a fabulous thing you're doing. Only good can come of this idea. I wish I had a teacher like you.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  14. El Monko and Son says How about playing "Tales of Brave Ulysses" when doing The Odyssey?
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  15. Mike the Knife says You da man, kb. And, of course, the woman. Your job is the most important in the world, right up there with doctor/nurse. Thanks for choosing it as a profession and, apparently, giving a damn. BTW, "Catcher..." was the book that had the most profound influence on me as a kid - other than "Goldfinger" and a few select issues of "Justice League of America."
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  16. shayna says very very cool. reminds me of some of the stuff my mom is doing in her writing classes (screenwriting, journalism and literature). I'm a big believer in challenging some of the ideas and structures that have become the norm in education. if any of my teachers approached things this way...I would've gotten a lot more out of the public schools!
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  17. kb says aww, thanks everyone. feels really incredible, i may add, to get the mog-support.
    Permalink posted 01/08/2007
  18. sammyeatworld says When I read Catcher in the Rye I always imagine Bright Eyes songs in the background. Y'know, the whole, cynical, lonely, adolecent semi-emo theme. Plus, I always imagined him to look like Conor. And Bright Eyes + Catcher in the Rye are my favourite artist and book respectively... Tee hee...
    Permalink posted 01/09/2007
  19. Jonh Ingham says We can only praise you. I generally had really ordinary teachers, but my senior year English teacher saw something and encouraged me. The "life stuff" he showed me has resonated to this day. Incidentally, his music awareness programme was introducing me to Lalo Schiffrin - good choice. Somewhere in your classes are some kids who will remember all this stuff and be that bit different from the sheep. Keep at it!
    Permalink posted 01/09/2007
  20. leftoverking says great book, great lesson plan there kb!
    Permalink posted 01/10/2007
  21. kaluss says those kids will certainly remember their english teacher......nice phish choice.
    Permalink posted 01/12/2007
  22. Anonymous says JUST finished reading King Dork and have never read Catcher. Now I'm wondering if I should. I'm not that keen on "the classics of literature," though it varies.
    Permalink posted 01/14/2007
  23. 2Serenity says That's a great assignment! My English teachers were excellent back in the day too to the point that I majored in English and considered going for the PhD in English Literature but I decided to go ahead and be a capitalist and make money! =) But, I continue to have my love for learning. In fact, I am thinking of teaching on the graduate level so I guess we all have an inner teacher in us! Catcher in the Rye was one of my favorite books. I still refer to it in conversation and in life with people. It really made an impact on how I see the world. For me, I see many of us as the Holden Caulfield character. Sick of the phonies and trying to rescue those from going down that terrible path. When I watched the movie, Mean Girls, for some reason I just kept on thinking - Well, what would Holden Caulfield do? Great post! Thanks for sharing!
    Permalink posted 06/18/2007
  24. 2Serenity says That's a great assignment! My English teachers were excellent back in the day too to the point that I majored in English and considered going for the PhD in English Literature but I decided to go ahead and be a capitalist and make money! =) But, I continue to have my love for learning. In fact, I am thinking of teaching on the graduate level so I guess we all have an inner teacher in us! Catcher in the Rye was one of my favorite books. I still refer to it in conversation and in life with people. It really made an impact on how I see the world. For me, I see many of us as the Holden Caulfield character. Sick of the phonies and trying to rescue those from going down that terrible path. When I watched the movie, Mean Girls, for some reason I just kept on thinking - Well, what would Holden Caulfield do? Great post! Thanks for sharing!
    Permalink posted 06/18/2007
  25. kb says thanks for your comment, 2serenity...appreciate it!
    Permalink posted 06/19/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved