THE MUSIC BLOGGING HIVE MIND

Devendra Banhart's latest

Posted over 2 years ago
I reviewed Devendra's latest album Smokey Rolls Down Thunder Canyon last week for Dusted -- and also did an interview with him (which isn't finished yet and won't run for a while). Here's a bit from the review:Over the last few years, Devendra Banhart has evolved from a fragile outsider artist, recording on other people's answering machines (Oh Me Oh My), to a favored protégé of Swans/Young God's Michael Gira (Rejoicing in the Hands, Nino Roja), to the acknowledged center of the freak-folk universe (Cripple Crow), to, finally, the oddball connection between people as disparate as Beck, Karl Lagerfeld, Gael Garcia Bernal and Vashti Bunyan. His latest incarnation and fifth album, Smokey Rolls Down Thunder Canyon, is not, perhaps, as seamlessly lovely as Rejoicing in the Hands. It is not as utterly unique and self-revealing as Oh Me Oh My. It rambles all over the place, in terms of genre and influence, as Cripple Crow did, and there are a few cringe-worthy moments ("Shabop Shalom" is pretty bad). And yet to complain about excesses or discontinuity or questionable judgment is to miss the whole point. This is Devendra Banhart…eclectic and whimsical and poking genres with a stick to see if they'll bite. It's a little mad, a lot overstuffed, and probably a degree or two calculated. Still it's intermittently very beautiful – and what other artist can count Linda Perhacs, Vashti Bunyan, the Black Crowes’ Chris Robinson and Gael Garcia Bernal as backup players? (The rest is here: http://www.dustedmagazine.com/reviews/3831)

Comments (5)

  1. fistula spume says Sounds cool to me. I like Devendra quite a bit. Always interested in where he's going. You never know. He's a bit of an enigma. How is the Linda Perhacs track?
    Permalink posted 09/17/2007
  2. max says so far the highlights for me are "lover" and "carmencita"...haha, i actually kind of like "shabop shalom", maybe it's just because it was so epic at his show last week, but on the whole i'm not super impressed with this album. You have to kind of sift through it to find it's moments.
    Permalink posted 09/17/2007
  3. jenny says Max, yes, I agree with you...my favorite Devendra albums are still Rejoicing in the Hands and (slightly behind) Oh Me Oh My. The latter stuff can be unbelievably beautiful (that "Dragonflies" song on Cripple Crow just kills me) but, as you say, you have to pick your way. I am sort of fond of Devendra and there's something very appealing about his passion for all kinds of music...so when i hear something of his that I don't like, I tend to FF to the next rather than agonize about it. I think it's good that he's around and if he weren't so out-there, he would never get to a lot of the places he goes...some of which are very worth going to. If that makes sense. I think Michael Gira was probably a real stabilizing influence on Devendra's music. There's a lot more sticking to the point and refusing to go off on tangents in the first few albums where he was involved. And Fistula (sorry, I don't know your actual name), Linda Perhacs is really just singing backup. She has a lovely voice, of course, but it's not like the Vashti duet on Rejoicing where you have a sort of marriage of equals.
    Permalink posted 09/17/2007
  4. fistula spume says It's Sam. I was hoping for something monumental after he was so stoked about hooking up with Linda. I love her. She sent me a lovely note when I ordered Parallelograms from her last year. It said "love, Linda." at the end. It made it feel oh so personal. Great stuff.
    Permalink posted 09/17/2007
  5. jenny says You know, I still haven't heard Parallelograms, Sam. I think she's on "Seaside", beautiful song...maybe it will mean more to you since you're familiar with her work. I spoke to Vashti Bunyan a year or two ago, and she was very sweet (and very surprised at all the uproar about her, as well).
    Permalink posted 09/18/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved