WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

"indie rock collective conscious?" or "why does your mix tape sound like his mixtape?"

Posted over 2 years ago
After class I was perusing the Mog-O-Sphere, when I stumbled across Anna’s post about mix tape rules. As I began to comment, I began to ramble, as I have a tendency to do. I decided that my rambling rant would serve better as a post and spare all of Anna’s dedicated readers from being subjected to my slightly related mix tape rant. So, without further ado, I present to you a post that Mog attempted to leave behind through a conspiracy of technical difficulties, but through hard work and dedication I prevailed and posted my blog… I was at work the other day, when my friend Wimpy dropped off his weekly Mix CD for the store. This caused everyone to drop what they were doing and check out the track list, which always invokes a series of ooohs and ahhs. A friend of mine managed to push his way through the crowd to the front where he proceeded to make a checklist of bands that he has included on a mix that he had made earlier in the week. Both tapes included 5 similar artists which is roughly a 33.3% rate of similar artists one of them being Ben Folds. This clicked in my head as odd, but as I mentally retrieved track lists from previous mixes that I had encountered I realized that over the past 10 years (since the release of whatever and ever amen) Ben Folds (in some why, shape or form) has been featured on roughly 60-75% of all of the mix tapes/CDs that I have encountered. Then I started thinking about this some more… it seems as if the smiths have a high rate of appearance as well, and there was a 4 or 5 year period when no mix tape could escape the strangle hold of Belle and Sebastian. So, my question is: if all of these mix tapes are made by individuals who pride themselves on their individuality, then why does the track list seem to be dictated by some form of indie-rock collective consciousness? Also, how did the white belt reach indie-iconic status overnight? I could go one but I will spare you all. I guess for now, by default, Ben Folds is……The King of The Mix! Or maybe not.

Comments (10)

  1. elketerbentzadik says I've never put a Ben Folds song on a mixtape.
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  2. deadmandeadman says There are far more than one collective conscience. We are all tapped into many. No two people are completely in sync. There is the herd. There are sheepdogs. There are buzzards watchin'. There are wolves and wolf wanna-be's. I don't own anything by ben folds five. I've made a ba-jillion mixes.
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  3. etcvisitor says ive never put a ben folds song on a mix either and ive also made a ba-jillion mixes, but it seems that every time i get in someones car and their playing a mix CD that some friend gave them low and behold there he is, or anytime i pick up a random mix at work and pop it in he is on there. maybe it's just me, but this has been the norm not only here in tennessee but also this has been my experience in ohio as well. i dont know...
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  4. deadmandeadman says I'm hearin' the Twilight Zone Theme
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  5. chucky says I'm sure that I've put Ben Folds on a mix before. Heh. Maybe it's a ripple effect. Person A gives it to person B who shares it with person C until it's everywhere.
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  6. deadmandeadman says True enough, chucky
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  7. spaceling says Originality is in the mix, not the ingredients. Also, some ingredients just taste really good.
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  8. ColdandComposed says Well, here in Wisconsin/Iowa I'd never heard of Ben Folds until 05. Never on a mix CD I'd gotten. Obviously I know who he is though...................... I would imagine in TN it'd be more rampant. Even though Ben spends a fair amount of time touring up here.
    Permalink posted 01/29/2007
  9. Anna says I like your eloquent, witty rambles, Henry, you needn't worry. I’ve never put a Ben Folds song on a mixtape, either, nor would I. I don't believe he's very well known here, and I don't believe that we can relate to the sound anyways. I guess it's more of an American thing. That aside, if we all unique, but only some are one of a kind, then how many of us are individual? Heh. Meaning that we are all individuals. But there's a diff between being an individual & being unique. Collective consciousness is everywhere, we can't escape it, so we might as well enjoy it. Great post.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2007
  10. etcvisitor says i still want to know who gave the go signal on white belts.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2010 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved