digital music habits and selection

Posted over 5 years ago
lately i've been thinking about how digital music affects the way that we select music to listen to. i have noticed several really strange things since switching to (mostly) digital listening:1. the 'nothing looks appealing' syndrome - i don't know how many times i have scrolled through dozens and dozens of artists in my ipod artist list, and found absolutely nothing that seems appetizing. it's a very odd phenomenon, because it is all music that i like very much, and have carefully selected to be placed on the ipod. however, i usually end up putting it on random, and i then enjoy nearly every song that comes up. i am convinced that this syndrome is due, in part, by the lack of a physical package. if you have a stack of albums, or even CDs, the typical selection involves flipping through them until a piece of album art catches your eye, which triggers impressions, memories, feelings, and other associations that result in an impulse to hear the music associated to that package. 2. accidental alphabetical listening habits - i just listened to the new cursive record. when it finished up, naturally, itunes went to the next alphabetical artist, which happened to be curt kirkwood. i probably would not have chosen to listen to curt kirkwood today, but as soon as the first few seconds kicked in, i fully committed to listening to that record in completion as well. 3. shorter attention span - all this immediate access to tons of music, i feel, makes us less capable of sitting through entire albums. i am an album guy. i like to take in an album as a piece of art, in order, as the artist planned it. i find that it is more difficult to commit to listening to a full album nowadays, or i get anxious to get to something else -- simply because it's all there at the touch of a button. i somehow think that if i had to lift a needle, place an album back into a sleeve and then pull another album out of the stacks and then remove it from its sleeve and then place it on the turntable and then put the needle down, i would not be inclined to change what is on.4. alphabetically weighted artists - i find more and more that bands with names beginning with letters later in the alphabet get less listens than those with names which start with the earlier letters. simply because our ipods and our players sort them by default a-z. we accept this and scroll accordingly until we see something appealing and we click on it. unless of course, you have the 'nothing looks appealing' syndrome, in which you will scroll a-z two to three times without finding anything. i have started scrolling from z lately to counteract this. oh i'm sure there are more things i have noticed, but i don't have the attention span to continue.

Comments (12)

  1. max says ya know it's weird, i've experienced a lot of those same kinds of things after i started getting more mp3's, weird
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  2. Kate says Whenever I feel myself getting that yucky short-attention span feeling I just go back to my favorite old standby- vinyl. The meditative act of looking through my records, taking in the sleeve art and enjoying the warm sound always chills out my hyperactive mind.
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  3. safronia says yes, it's all true. i listen to my ipod almost exclusively on shuffle now, and i used to be an album girl too. when i had a cd player in my car, i would listen to one album for a week or more straight. i could identify most songs in my collection within three notes. now my collection is full of music that i love, but when my friends ask who is the artist, most times i have no idea without looking it up. the funny thing is that when i come across a song on shuffle from an old album that i know by heart, i immediately want to listen to the album all the way through. i need to condition myself in the same manner with my new music.
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  4. fiercek says wow, just last night i was talking to my friend about everything you said in #1 . and he has actually eased me back into the album listening habit...except that i often break it because listening to some song on an album reminds me of some other song that i really want to hear "at the touch of a button" (#3) as for #2, i will skip a few artists down or up after one album finishes (if i let it) and so i listen to artists in alphabetical clusters i think i'm ok with #4, because i always go to the bottom to look for spoon (just as i do in record stores), it's my teddy bear of music..and that starts me off in different directions too
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  5. LadyC says your on the spot, especially the first and last point. i don't own a record player so i usually throw on a CD and take out the cover and go through it, listening from beg-end but it HAS completely changed my listening habits, kinda sad isnt it?
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  6. Emme says Having just finished toiling away for many an hour on some album artwork for an upcoming Secretly Canadian release, I can't help but wonder how many people won't see it! Maybe - just maybe - they'll see a small "thumbnail" JPEG of the cover online but who will read the lovingly designed booklet or notice the painstakingly composed back cover? Just as well I'm designing a website to match!
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  7. Killa says i concur. i was really iffy about putting my digital music up here on mog because to be honest, i like to see alot of live music, and i DO listen to alot of single songs rather than albums, so the artists you see when you open my page are the ones i have a substantial amount of music by, and i was also scurred cause i just got my mac a few months ago and actually...still listen to physical cds in my car...and don't own an ipod, because i'm a broke mofo who can't make a comitment or settle for less than 60G. and as soon as i like more than a song or two by a band i buy their album on amazon and obsess about it for at least a week, as is the case with Broken Social Scene....so i too appreciate the value of an album as an entire work
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  8. chucky says It's like you plucked the thoughts right out of my head on #1 and #3. I used to pop in one cd and listen to it for month, sometimes 3 months. Now, I never listen to cds anymore. In fact, I don't even buy whole albums anymore. I buy single tracks only. And then I just hit the next button over and over again. I don't have the same connection with my music that I used to have. I hadn't even thought about #4, but you are right.
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  9. inmostlight says I've encountered the same problem. I'm buying more music than ever (both digital and physical), but don't really get to appreciate too many of them. A few years ago, each morning I'd sit down at the CD collection and choose a set of albums to take with me to work. I kind of miss that ritual, and I don't listen to old tracks as often or albums all the way through any more. But on the other hand, now if I'm having a rough day and really need to hear something like Ministry's "Stigmata", I'm guaranteed to have it along with several thousand other songs in my pocket. I still haven't decided if the new way is better or worse yet.
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  10. fiercek says hmmm sort of related, although this is detrimental to the album listening part "list of bands from A-Z":http://greatbodyofwater.blogspot.com/2006/07/bands-to-z-finished.html
    Permalink posted 07/11/2006
  11. iwantsomecouch says good observations, because they seem to all be true. i find myself never finding something i want to listen to. music loses its replay value as entries in an xml database, as opposed to being nestled away in a sleeve or case, a treasure to open again. and looking through a library alphabetically deteriorates the playing habits of what is otherwise a diverse library. if only iTunes could shuffle by album...
    Permalink posted 07/12/2006
  12. MilesTrane says yea great post. i'd personally love it if they (iTunes or other) added an artist and/or album shuffle/randomizer as opposed to simply tracks. it's time for next gen shuffle
    Permalink posted 07/16/2006

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved