WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

Jules Shear covers "I'll Be Seeing You"

Posted about 1 year ago
  • Artist:
  • Album:
    Live on Vin Scelsa's "Idiot's Delight" radio show
  • Track:
    I'll Be Seeing You

I was unfamiliar with this song until I heard a version, back in the mid-60s, from an album by The Lettermen that my sister owned. I liked it then, I like it now. But I love this version, done solo by Jules Shear on Vin Scelsa's radio show. It illustrates Jules' ability to strip a song to its emotional core.

I was surprised to read on Wikipedia that the song stems from 1938, was featured in a 1940s musical, and a 1944 Joseph Cotton/Ginger Rogers movie by the same name, and was much beloved in the WWII era, when I'm sure it illustrated the feelings of those with loved ones overseas fighting Hitler. It was a #1 hit for Bing Crosby in 1944.

The song has been covered close to 600 times, with a list of artists including:

Martha Wainwright

Rickie Lee Jones

Gene Pitney

Linda Ronstadt

Tony Bennett

The Carpenters

Judy Collins

The Four Freshmen

Comments (15)

  1. deadmandeadman says

    I gues we'll have to wait for Dylan to record the definitive version, huh?

    So,  you like this but you didn't like Sonic Youth's version of SuperStar? WTF?  LOL  I like this a lot. He sounds like a friggin' stalker.

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  2. dermahrk says

    Superstar is a horrible song to begin with. Then add a horrible performance by "art rockers" (oh, puh-leeze) and you have something more full of crap than a porta-pottie at a rock festival. But I'm glad you like this!

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  3. deadmandeadman says

    Tell me how you really feel

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  4. deedee says

    One of the best. songs. ever. I think my favorite is Billie Holiday's. Few singers include the introductory verse: "Cathedral bells were tolling/As our hearts sang on/Was this the thrill of Paris/or the April dawn?/ Who knows if we shall meet again?/But when the morning chimes ring sweet again...."

    And a shout-out to Vin Scelsa, who was a radio pal to many of us NYC kids for decades. I wrote to him way back in '80, and I still have his reply.  Love Vinnie.

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  5. DaveCromwell says

    Sonic Youth can do whatever the fuck they want ;-)

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  6. deadmandeadman says

    "Sonic Youth can do whatever the fuck they want  ;-)"

    I second that emotion

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  7. indiepixie says

    Cool new avatar dermahrk. and thanks for the history lesson :)_

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  8. Rawkkiddoh says

    I have heard the Carpenters version and loved it. Have to say I love this version that much more though

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  9. dermahrk says

    Yes, Sonic Youth can do whatever they want but, like my neighbors' dog, I'd appreciate it if their shit is not left on my lawn. ;-)

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  10. BrandNewFriend says

    Great post-- great track-- and great last comment derm

    I liked the Carpenters version and as deedee the Billy Holiday version but this is pretty cool

    cheers derm x

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  11. ivylander says

    This legitimately rivals the cover version (which you didn't mention) by Iggy Pop and Francoise Hardy. No, it really exists.... 

    Permalink posted 08/31/2008
  12. MusicRX says

    "something more full of crap than a porta-pottie at a rock festival."

    Best descriptive commentary ever! LOL

    Permalink posted 09/01/2008
  13. The Time Machine says

    Surprised that you weren't familiar with how famous this song is and how many artists have covered it.  My favorite use of the song was back in the late eighties or early nineties when CBS or one of the networks aired an animated special of "The Far Side".  A wolf sat in a cave watching an old film watching his or her mate play around with a hunters camera.  Very sad and has left an impression that has never left my head since that show aired. 

    Jules does a wonderful take on this classic song.

    Thanks for posting this.

    Permalink posted 09/02/2008
  14. skamzoo says

    I'm right there with you Time Machine.  I remembr exactly how moving that animation was.  I've been searching the web for it recently but no joy.

    Permalink posted 02/12/2009
  15. The Time Machine says

    As far as I know it was never released on VHS or DVD.  Maybe someday it will make a repeat broadcast. 

    :=)

    Permalink posted 02/12/2009

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2010 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved