MELT-PROOF AND SCRATCH-RESISTANT
dermahrk
dermahrk
Add To My Trusted Moggers

My favorite off of the new McCartney

Posted about 1 year ago
While I like a lot of Paul's new CD, I must admit that this song is my fave. The first time I heard I thought : "Whoa, his voice is really going", as it sounded weak and strained. Yet, the more I heard it the more I grew to love that vocal, because it seemed to encompass fragility. It may well be the most emotional-sounding Macca vocal ever. But besides that, I think the melody is stellar, the instrumentation perfect and, who knows? - it might even be about that *"one-legged bitch":http://mog.com/dermahrk/blog_post/50192*
0

Comments (15)

  1. deadmandeadman
    deadmandeadman says He's got a new cd? Yawn. But I'm listenin' now outta respect for your unerring ear for good music, (your affinity for pappy pop notwithstanding). >>>OK, maybe I need a few more listens. LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  2. Lester Jonze
    Lester Jonze says You know, I have had this since it came out and I have yet to listen to it. Boy do I suck.
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  3. Imogenery
    Imogenery says Macca never disappoints (well, at least that's what I think). "You Tell Me" is no exception. Great stuff.
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  4. Spike
    Spike says Imogenery, I hope your comment doesn't mean that you like EVERY song he's written. Even God isn't perfect all the time. On the other hand (she wore a glove), "You Tell Me" sounds perfect. dermahrk, your review describes my response perfectly.
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  5. dermahrk
    dermahrk says There are few Macca boosters bigger than I, but EVERY song? You'd have to be brain-dead.
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  6. bryan-j
    bryan-j says Don't like that 1,2,3 opening - then I thought it was Neil Young's "Heart of Gold". (Must post that soon) I wanted to say it proves that age is no barrier to talent, which it isn't, but this isn't about age. It's pretty bland, I'm sorry to say. I wanted to like it as he's such a working class hero - unless you are a living ex-wife.
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  7. lovestoned
    lovestoned says hey thanks for checking out my Mog/Blog~ i was so excited to see that someone had posted about The Bridges~ they are awesome and they need to be heard! :-)
    Permalink posted 01/20/2008
  8. scotfree
    scotfree says just curios, does the recording sound like what you've posted? the production is way weird. that hissing (electronic?)percussion seems way out of place. and the acoustic guitar is so (over) compressed. that said, the emotion still shines through, just think it should have been done straight up
    Permalink posted 01/21/2008
  9. Imogenery
    Imogenery says Spike and dermahrk: I didn't say every song nor did I say anything about constant perfection; I was speaking in a very general sense. So no, I'm not brain dead.
    Permalink posted 01/22/2008
  10. dermahrk
    dermahrk says I never intended to imply that you were. God forbid I should offend another Macca booster on this site. There are NO artists that generate output that I love 100% of the time. And I think Spike is much too much of a gentleman to have intended that either. Friends?
    Permalink posted 01/22/2008
  11. Imogenery
    Imogenery says I can't say I love 100% of the output of any artist I enjoy either. Like I said, just a very general comment I made back there. ;) Anyway, no love lost. Friends. :)
    Permalink posted 01/22/2008
  12. Jonh Ingham
    Jonh Ingham says I've been coming back to this again and again over a few days. It's a real grower. Maybe it *is* about the one-legged one.
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  13. uncle creepy
    uncle creepy says good listen to my ear on 1st play, yeah yeah Mr. DJ. I confess I'd never heard give liquor back to the licorice until the other nite, so I'm no Macca expert. Liked em both. Interesting in any case to finally hear a world weary Paulie lay down all the perky puffery some may find in his public persona.. We knew he was a mensch from the gatefold of his 1st post-Beatles lp. But this! Presume you've cringed to the new Ringo single... "Liverpool We Were From" or what... it's Ringo's new guitarist who's taking up the cause of Dolly! (baaaad joke, sorry!)
    Permalink posted 02/05/2008
  14. dermahrk
    dermahrk says Unfortunately, a joke I don't understand. Dolly? I own the new Ringo and "Liverpool 8", though it has some interesting lyrical content, is one of the low points on the CD, musically. Uninteresting melody & changes. Why pick that as the single? I think any track with a heavy Beatles reference automatically gets picked as the single. But the rest of the CD is pretty stellar. I will probably post a track or two. That new avatar - Ringo as the Breck girl from the back of one of the mid-60s MAD magazine, yes? Brings back memories...
    Permalink posted 02/06/2008
  15. uncle creepy
    uncle creepy says Dolly - clone - sheep - baaa - baaaad! Yeah, "Liverpool 8" must have been picked as the single for the Beatles reference. Better Ringo was to had on the Weight of The World lp of several years back, with catchy tunes like "Runaway" and "Don't Go Where The Road Don't Go"...
    Permalink posted 02/08/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

Top Artists

Our Daily Picks

RSS

Top Artists From A to Z

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved