WE DO THE MASHED POTATO AND THE FUNKY CHICKEN

an old-fashioned love song

Posted about 1 year ago
It isn't an I’m-so-happy-I-could-die love song; it isn't teen infatuation (not that there’s anything wrong with that) or tormented torch. It's a mellow, wistful, grow-old-with-me declaration, rendered in the tenderest manner. Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein II wrote it in 1937; some of the usual suspects (Torme, Crosby, Grappelli, Hartman, Krall, Simone) have had a go at it. Here's Miss Peggy Lee, for whom it was said to be a favorite. She leaves out in the introductory verse, which goes thusly: Many men with lofty aims,Strive for lofty goals,Others play at smaller games,Being simpler souls.I am of the latter brand;All I want to do,Is to find a spot of land,And live there with you.She also made one interesting change, substituting "Baby and Joan" for "Darby and Joan," probably figuring (correctly) that most people wouIdn’t get the reference. I know I didn't at first, and now I am quite fond of it. "Darby and Joan," it turns out, is a term-- probably better know to our Brit friends (and Lee's recording, as it happens, was more popular in the U.K.)-- that means “a happily married couple who lead a placid, uneventful life” or "a symbol of a happy couple in advancing age." D & B were the subjects of a few poems by different poets in the 1700s and 1800s, and are alluded to in a few novels (Thackeray, Rendell, Henry James) as well. And if you’re my mate and me, watching the Brit sitcom As Time Goes By on a Saturday night as he does the puzzle and I read the book review, "that same old view" seems the perfect thing to aspire to.

Comments (6)

  1. Spike says It's hard to find anything wrong with that. Her voice and face betrayed no insincerity. The distant out-of-frame microphone captured her soft voice, and the orchestra's sound was perfect as well. What would life be without the book review?
    Permalink posted 04/25/2008
  2. ivylander says This is fully the equal of what has been, up until now, my favorite version of this song, by Jimmy Scott (see attached audio). Your mate is wise - anymore, the puzzles don't even get interesting until Friday.....
    Permalink posted 04/26/2008
  3. deedee says That's a divine version too (I think it's emscee's favorite)--alas, it's unavailable on youtube.
    Permalink posted 04/26/2008
  4. emscee says When a girl sings it, the song seems wistful and faraway, like an entry in a diary, a projection of a fantasy. It's as though she has a mad crush, and is outlining her perfect life. Nearly all the good female singers (Jo Stafford, Gloria Lynne, Miss Peggy Lee) have gone up the path to this house on the hill. I've been liking Carmen McRae's lately.
    Permalink posted 04/26/2008
  5. deedee says Interesting. And when a guy sings it...? I think what I find intriguing is that very few popular songs acknowledge aging at all, let alone find it an appealing thought. Hammerstein went down a similar path again in "When the Children Are Asleep," from Carousel : When the children are asleep/I'll dream with you/We'll think what fun we have had and be glad/That it's all came true.
    Permalink posted 04/26/2008
  6. emscee says When a guy sings it, it's a marriage proposal.
    Permalink posted 04/26/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved