WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

How Can You Say That You're Not Responsible?

Posted over 2 years ago
The Police are categorically my all-time favourite rock band in the history of rock bands. They have been for years and years and anyone who knows me know this. Of course, it doesn’t hurt that Sting is easy on the eyes, but that’s not the central appeal. It’s the solid, well-crafted pop magic that’s the appeal, to me at least. And after so many years of listening to their 5 studio albums, hearing any of those songs is like wrapping myself up in my favourite old sweater – familiar, comforting, still awesome after all these years.So it goes without saying that this reunion tour has me crazy excited … emphasis on crazy ‘cause I’ve spent nearly a half a grand on concert tickets. It’s ridiculous! I mean, here I am trying to get my financial act together, get a mortgage, buy a house – and I spend $500+ on The Police!? It sounds illogical, but in my head, it’s perfectly justified. This will (almost) certainly never happen again, and I’ve gone my whole life believing that it never would. Carpe diem and all that shit, right?Anyway, I was watching the Live Earth thing on TV, and The Police played Driven To Tears as the grand finale. It’s one of my faves, that song, but I have to say that I found the Live Earth version a little weak. I don’t blame John Mayer (He almost went unnoticed, no?) and I don’t even blame Kanye West (How awkward was that? I squirmed through all his ‘uh’s and ‘we can save the world’s – just didn’t fit, I thought). I blame the band and Andy Summers specifically. Maybe I’m just too fond of the album version and all its fancy studio twinkle, but there's an awesome little guitar riff in the chorus that was either missing, or drowned out in the Live Earth version. That little riff is an intergral part of what makes that song so fetch. I hope that this song will be on the set list when they play Toronto – and I hope that the riff makes its triumphant return to my eardrums. Not to be total hater, but I'm also getting a little sick of the jam band clusterfuck they call Roxanne these days. I'm all for breathing new life into an old song, but after 3 minutes of "Roxanne, Oh!" callbacks, even I start to lose interest. I'd like to say it'll be different live, but I've seen Roxanne performed this way live half a dozen times before at Sting shows, and I always found it the perfect time to go pee. There is a pretty sweet payoff in the end though, when things kick back in after the Phish-ing is over - a big rock flourish to knock you out of daydream. I love that part.(can you believe i actually slipped 'fetch' in there?)

Comments (17)

  1. Rawkkiddoh says The only performance I caught was Bon Jovi, and good old Richie seemed to creep me out something fierce. I wonder who waxes his chest
    Permalink posted 07/07/2007
  2. debzeppelin says You'd have to pay me an awful lot of money to wax Richie Sambora's chest. How he ever got with Denise Richards is a mystery to me.
    Permalink posted 07/07/2007
  3. Rawkkiddoh says come on deb, you play guitar you get the chicks.
    Permalink posted 07/07/2007
  4. Augusts1 says Just stopping by to say hello & welcome you to all that is the Mog. $500.00 is way more than I've ever paid to see an artist. I won't pay more than $50, even for my fav artists, but that's just me. It would be great to see The Police live though. Enjoy!
    Permalink posted 07/09/2007
  5. david hyman says nice post. welcome. any friend of rawkiddo....
    Permalink posted 07/09/2007
  6. debzeppelin says Thanks for the warm welcome you guys - I'm looking forward to reading your posts ... I have a lot of catching up to do!
    Permalink posted 07/09/2007
  7. Marigold says Welcome to mog. This is a great post. I enjoy when people share what makes them tick musically. Even though I do not enjoy the Police as much as you, I can relate to your love of them. All music lovers can relate to that. So what I am saying is that I enjoyed your post because you have shared your passion with us and it translates well. $500.00 bucks to go see the Stone Roses (my Police) would totally happen. I always tell my wife that if the Stone Roses ever did a reunion, I would want to be going over to England if that was the only place they were playing. Have fun at your show! I expect a mog report when you get back from it.
    Permalink posted 07/10/2007
  8. debzeppelin says Thanks Marigold - I had similar conversations with my friends about which bands they would spend that kind of coin on and the Stone Roses came up then too. Everyone has their "I don't care what it costs" band ... I'm just lucky that all the circumstances allow me to actually do it. For sure, I'll report back - after both shows!!
    Permalink posted 07/10/2007
  9. Marigold says I should amend my above comment a bit. Even though I do not enjoy the Police as much as you do. I do enjoy them and have great respect for what they have brought to music. One thing that I always enjoy about The Police is hearing the infuence of reggae music in some of their songs. Two shows! nice.
    Permalink posted 07/10/2007
  10. steve simon says nice post, here is my rushed review of MGM show(http://mog.com/steve_simon/blog_post/86273). don't worry, they will play truth hits everybody.......their set list is same everynight
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  11. ponchoandy says The Police have been getting mixed reviews for sure, and yes, they *do* play altered and/or extended versions of many of their best songs. Personally I was fine with this, even when the results turned to mud ("Synchronicity II," which seems to consistently be a trainwreck, for some reason) or corny arena-rock call-and-response singalongs (and yes, Sting does just that on "Roxanne" and "Regatta de Blanc," although he was charmingly understated about it, I thought: "Don't make me beg," he told the audience). The thing about the Police to me is, they're such great musicians, let them go off a little. I missed them in their heyday and was thrilled to get a second chance, and their show at Dodger Stadium totally lived up to my expectations. (Although I must admit, I don't think I would've spent $500 a ticket on it... we got our tix for $110 apiece on eBay!)
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  12. debzeppelin says Oh, I (only!?) paid $250 a ticket and I'm going to two back-to-back shows, so that's how it's gets to be $500. For the first show, I've got 7th row floor tickets, so I'm super psyched about it. Their heyday went down when my age was still in single digits, so this is definitely a once-in-a lifetime thing for me. I couldn't agree more about the tremendous musicianship - and I'm glad that they're being class acts about the pomp of a big rock show. I'm absolutely certain that even if the show(s) is/are total crap, I will proclaim it the best show I've ever seen in my life! I've never had such extreme anticipation for a concert before, it will be physically impossible for me to be dissapointed. Like steve simon, being in the 7th row may very well embellish the experience, which is just an awesome bonus. When it comes right down to it, I'd rather the altered/extended versions than just a carbon copy of the songs I already know like the back of my hand. Seeing as they are such great musicians, I'd like to see them take it once step further and really let loose on those extended/altered versions.
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  13. SamTheButcher says For my 2 cents, deb, I have to call you out on hatin' the extendo "Roxanne". They jammed out the middle on the R&RHoF broadcast in 2003; they jammed out the middle on the Hatfield Polytechnic show from 1979 they broadcast on VH1 Classic's "Rock Goes To College"; they jammed out the middle in the movie "URGH! A Music War" (1981); they jammed out the middle (a little) on disc 1 of The Police Live! (Boston, 1979); and they jammed out the middle on disc 2 (Atlanta, 1983). My point is...? Well, my point is that it's not just "these days". I think it's kind of funny that I've read things like "Sting's brought his jazzbo tendencies to the Police" (paraphrased) and the like, when they've been doing such things since they started. Not only that, but they all started in jazz bands, pretty much. Now...I'm on the opposite side of the fence as you. While the Police are also one of my favorite bands of all time, I'm not going to see them live. First, I figure there'll be a Hi Def DVD that I can buy. Second, I didn't have the money when tickets were first available for the Denver show, and when I got the money, I...just...couldn't do it. I was *ecstatic* when I heard they were re-forming, ecstatic to see them on the Grammys, I was considering joining the fan club for $100 just to get the presale tickets. I even watched the Live Earth broadcast. However, most of the stuff I've seen has been kind of ... well... weak. Not bad, Stewart is still my favorite drummer ever. But there's just something missing, *I* think. And it's not just that I want to see some obscure songs or some goofy reason to hold out. The one song I'd love to see them do live is "So Lonely", and I realised that after they'd already been through Denver. I think I'd still pay to see them live just for that one song. But...as you can tell, I've seen my share of live Police performances, albeit on TV. However, so far this year, I've seen Morrissey & Bloc Party and will be seeing the Cure at Red Rocks in October. Both Moz and BP have been fucking *amazing* shows that I'm so very glad I've gone to. The Cure, I've seen before, but I haven't been to Red Rocks in years, and my wife has never been, so this'll be a good show to go to for us. (Besides, one of "our songs" is "Just Like Heaven" :) I've said, had the Police played Red Rocks, I'd've gone, no matter what. But they played an indoor arena. I can watch the Synchronicity concert for that. :) Great post, though. Should've put that at the beginning instead of coming off all know-it-all asshole, huh? :)
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  14. debzeppelin says I guess with the "these days" part, I meant to say that everytime I've heard Roxanne played live, it's been pretty much the exact same extendo version. I don't know what's worse really - playing the song exactly as we always have known it, or playing this extendo version exactly the same way every at every live performance? But I speak only from my experience at Sting shows of the past 6-7 years and the more recent televised Police stuff (Grammys, Live Earth). Perhaps I need to see more performances to hear the difference. Maybe the difference is as plain as the nose on my face, but I just can't hear it? All possible ... I'll certainly be paying close attention (and not running off for a bathroom break) when Roxanne comes up on Sunday & Monday. I, for one, like the jazz influences (perhaps in the minority?), and I don't for a minute think that it's all Sting's doing. I guess my point is, if you're gonna jam, then try different stuff out. Isn't that the beauty of jamming? I'm not a musician, so I have no idea really, totally talking out of my ass now. Probably a good idea to shut it now! Thanks for your smart and thoughtful comment ... made me think about my stance! Well done. Should’ve put that at the beginning instead of coming off all defensive jerk, huh? :) It's all good - I enjoy the discussion.
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  15. debzeppelin says For the record, I don't think you came off know-it-all asshole at all :)
    Permalink posted 07/18/2007
  16. SamTheButcher says Oh, I agree, it is pretty much the same extendo version, and I guess that's also the reason I agree with you that if you're gonna jam, JAM fer crissakes, and not just phone it in. Which is what they *seem* to be doing, which is why I'm not that disappointed on having missed the shows. Again, though, "So Lonely" is my song and I would've paid just to see that one tune, had I remembered on time. :( A friend of mine went to one of the shows here in Denver and she said that they were starting with extended openings, and one of her peeves was not knowing what song they were playing until 12 seconds into it. Maybe I'm trying to undersell it for you so you go in expecting so little that they blow you away. :) On the other side, I had a friend go to the June 10th show and he *loved* it. Here's his take, and his comment from someone who mentioned a bad review of the Minneapolis show: "Awesome. Incredible. Kick ass. These were the adjectives that came naturally like sighs after an awesome orgasm. Was it the best live concert I've ever seen? No, not by a long-shot. But it was a very satisfying show, even considering that I flew halfway across the country and spent a record amount on my ticket. No new songs, lots of new arrangements, some experimentation with time signatures. Sting is enjoying performing, Andy seems to be more or less putting his time in and Stewart is *better* than he used to be." "The reviewer was certainly not receptive to their experimentation with time signatures and arrangements that also characterized the show I saw in Denver, but the band may have simply had an off night, I dunno. I think it is interesting to watch musical experimentation even when it is not so successful, maybe that's the difference between the reviewer and I. I'm not looking for a live jukebox experience, i.e., I attended the show specifically because I was interested in what *changes* there would be to their performances 20 years down the road. I have live recordings if I simply want to re-live the 80's." So...You're either in for a great or boring time. I can't wait to read which you get. :D
    Permalink posted 07/19/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved