IF YOU SEE HER SAY HELLO

Posted over 3 years ago
On September 12, 1974 **Bob Dylan** walked into the studio and recorded one of the most remarkable song of his (or anyone else's) career, **If You See Her Say Hello**. A song of stark, naked emotional loss, a haunted yowl of regret as Dylan examines the still oozing scars of a shattered relationship. The song startles the listener as the narrator by turn rages, whimpers, wails an belies all attempts at acceptance. Its a truly exceptional song, masterfully performed (lived).>>>>Perhaps Bob startled himself when he listened to the playback. Maybe this most private and guarded artist felt he left himself too exposed. Whatever. In December of the same year he recorded the version that would be on **Blood On The Tracks**. In this newer version the narrator has had more time to adjust. Not enough time, but more. His pain is still apparent through the veneer of his old-world gentility. The somber organ notes & the mandolin, coupled with the (tex-mex?) guitars embue the proceedings with sepia tones, late afternoon sunlight streaming into the veranda. Yet the pain is still there, burbling just below the surface....??">>And I've never gotten used to it,I just learned to turn it offEither I'm too sensitive Or else I'm gettin soft."??Again, Bob's performance is almost heartbreaking in it's suppressed intensity, and breathtaking in it'sbrutal, raw yet refined delivery.So first up, From **The Bootleg Series**??If You See Her Say HellO??

Comments (14)

  1. ivylander says This is beautiful. Really beautiful.
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  2. deadmandeadman says From **Blood On The Tracks**, ~uUcsH8CQ6rs.mp3~
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  3. inrumford says Is this from the NY sessions?
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  4. Cody B says So are you saying Mr.Bob is human? I thought he just used people to further his own goals. At least that's what some say. To me the records of this time were the most personal he did and you scoped out a real winner. Usually outtakes, odds,sods, and bonus track collections just prove why the tunes are not on the original albums, but the Bootleg 1-3 set stands alone and apart as a great collection in its own right.
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  5. waydutch says Hey, good to see you. Saw this today and thought of you. I'll order one up for you if you promise to put it on your car!
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  6. Petey Lapides says I find the vocals on the non-??Blood?? version incalculably more humane, warm, nuanced, bristling with pain. Not to be too harsh, but the ??Blood?? version finds him whining and braying in full self-parody mode. Maybe he takes the affected approach to keep the original emotions at arm's length. As you suggested. Our loss, but for the bootleg. I'm not sure I've ever used the word "bristling" before.
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  7. redmiller1 says The guitar is more in tune on the bootleg version, too.
    Permalink posted 05/30/2008
  8. downhome says i love this version. i think bob says somewhere in one of his interviews (almost as amazing a group of inventions, in some way, as his music) that the thing that distinguishes his work is a quality of "gallantry.'' again, i speak of his work, not his life, about which we can only guess, but certainly this song exemplifies that trait.
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  9. gerekriss says Gorgeous.
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  10. deadmandeadman says One can easily imagine that this song may dredge up some uncomfortable feelings in the Author, so live versions are not common. When he ??does?? bring it out its usually radically reworked, (surprise!), retooled, & revised. A Rehearsal for the '78 tour is a case in point. ~Zou1F4Cg0y3.mp3~
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  11. marknavl says Very coincidental that we both posted from this album at nearly the same time yesterday. I've always loved this song.Great post!
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  12. Bartleby says It's a beautiful piece of bitter-sweet self-pity. A confession of loss and yearning: "If she's passing back this way/I'm not that hard to find/Tell her she can look me up/If she's got the time." The bootleg version is a sigh in the night, which even the production of the finished version cannot quite conceal. Brilliant post, DMDM.
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  13. Sturgell says heavy post. Really puts another perspective on a classic tune. Thanks.
    Permalink posted 05/31/2008
  14. fastnbulbous says I just saw I'm Not There. Like Haynes other movies, it's pretentious as all hell, but there's some great parts. The sections with Heath Ledger could really have been enhanced by this song.
    Permalink posted 06/02/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved