WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

The Band. Shine A Light

Posted about 1 month ago

.....From the first "post-Robertson" Band album...1993's Jericho was a great, if unfairly overlooked, album.

Comments (5)

  1. DetroitBob says

    Very good song but also one that exemplifies the problem of the post-Robertson group- they lost their lyricist. As great as Danko was and Helm and Hudson are musically, songwriters they were/are not.

    Permalink posted 10/10/2009
  2. deadmandeadman says

    Well Bob,  yes n no.  One could make a legitimate argument that Mr J.R. Robertson was an over-rated lyricist. Very often his (almost embaressing) lyrics are brought alive by stunning performances.  It Makes No Difference being a great example.

    ....I liked Jericho, & still do, because it updates, without abandoning, the Band's sound.  The vocals by turn & Garth's friendly eeerie keyboard work really shine.  If the lyric is weak...and thats not a given, it is so in comparison only to The Band's very highest peaks.

    Permalink posted 10/10/2009
  3. DetroitBob says

    Of course the lyrics and performance are great, but my point was that nobody in The Band had a part in its writing... Marty Grebb and Daniel Moore wrote "Shine A Light". Of the thirty-five songs released by The Band in the 1990s, twenty-one were interpretations of the works of others. Of the fourteen originals or semi-originals, eight were on 1998's Jubilation.

    Permalink posted 10/10/2009
  4. MusicRX says

    Still...I like it.

    Permalink posted 10/10/2009
  5. deadmandeadman says

    ...and further still.... Interpreting the works of others has long been a part of The Band's oeuvre.

    Permalink posted 10/10/2009

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved