cogwheeldogs
cogwheeldogs of Cogwheel Dogs

White Chalk - aesthetically brilliant (PJ Harvey)

Posted over 4 years ago

Well, I have just been listening to the new PJ Harvey album, White Chalk. Below, a few impressions.

The first is the album artwork. Which I like very much. Pared-down, tasteful, attention-grabbing, unpretentious. And I am an unashamed doter upon uncoated card (rough, textured, matt).

With the opening track, the first thing I think of - curiously, and rather unexpectedly - is the The Beach Boys. It's not quite 'I Get Around', I know. But there's a tightness and buoyancy to the opening piano chords that's oddly reminiscent. In general, PJ Harvey's piano playing is very interesting.

In some ways it reminds me of listening to untaught pianists at school, playing pop songs on the Chapel piano. (Yes, my school had a chapel. My school had a whole lot of things that its senior management considered badges of gravitas, respectability and grandeur.) PJH approaches the piano, somehow, as if for the first time. That is, on this album, she seems to tap into a sort of pianistic naivety - sees the instrument's potential in a manner unclouded by formal lessons and classical techniques.

Piano is explored, on White Chalk, as a 'new' instrument. Technically, the playing is generally fairly simplistic - but that's really not the point. At intervals, we hear it played as if it were a palm-muted guitar (tight, repeating chords, no cross-rhythms, deliberately dampened), 'strummed', and playing simple, lovely figures such as the spidery, gossamer opening of 'Dear Darkness' (complemented sensitively by the feather-light brushed drums later in the track).

I think of Kid A/Amnesiac-era Radiohead quite a bit when listening to this album. Which might not always be auspicious ... but, in this case, is. In the excellent 'Grow Grow Grom' (one of the standout tracks), for instance, an irregular time-signature is not employed through clever-clever 'I can count better than you' gimmickry, but is integral to the song, and justified by it. This reminds me of Radiohead's 'Pyramid Song'.

... More than of Radiohead, I think of The Smashing Pumpkins - specifically, Adore (easily my favourite of that band's albums, and underappreciated generally). The link may be partly explained by the fact that both Adore and White Chalk are characterised by a move from guitar towards the more unfamiliar piano.

... But most of all, I think of early 20th century composers – primarily Benjamin Britten, but also Ralph Vaughan Williams. In songs such as 'Grow Grow Grom' and 'Silence', there's a colouristic use of harmony - by which I mean that unusual chords enter the music not so much to carry it foward into new areas, but to add vibrant, unexpected splashes of new colour. A previously minor chord in a sequence may become major, say, yet not affect the rest of the sequence (as it would in 'classical' harmony). In 'Grow Grow Grom', there are some beautiful shifts of key centre (as opposed to key changes), which seems to me very Britten-esque. And the whole song is characterised by a persistent shifting back and forth between two chords (two colours) that don't quite go together - but don't clash. It is delicate, intelligent, efficient and - above all - painterly writing - sparse and moving, with every element contributing to the whole.

'Broken Harp' is only 1:59 long (I applaud the brevity of many of these songs - in tune with the minimalist instrumentation, songs are never allowed to venture anywhere near the gratuitous or the expansive). It sounds old. Like an English folk song. And, like good folk, it manages simultaneously to sound fragile, delicate - almost brittle - and incredibly robust. Later in the song (and not for the first time on the album), the vocals lean in the direction of Björk.

'Broken Harp' and the immediately following three tracks ('Silence', 'To Talk To You' and 'The Piano') are brilliant, together (and, no doubt, independently also). 'Silence', with its pulsing piano, seems to drive forward, but the persistently descending chordal figures contradict this momentum; and 'To Talk To You' employs a different kind of polarity, with very high, tremulous vocals set against a muffled, bass-heavy, "sluggish" piano sound. There are qualities of Tori Amos's 'Bells for Her' (a great song), with its treated piano sounds, imparting an exotic, bell-like, slightly ring-modulated quality – vaguely reminiscent of Gamelan, somehow. The whole song ('To Talk to You') sounds at times as if it's been recorded on an old, degraded tape. The vibrato effect on vocals and piano creates a fantastic texture that is astonishingly tangible-seeming - makes me feel as though I could almost run my finger along the serrated edge of the sound, like stroking the blades of a comb.

Then 'The Piano' picks up momentum, with strange, excellent trilling figures making darting flights and retreats onto another pulsing, tapping piano/percussion background. Then we hear the lyric "Rattling his keys" – and realise that these trills were superb anticipatory word-painting of an entirely non-gratuitous kind.

It's a fantastic song - powerful and evocative, disturbing ... After which, the sinking, melancholic piano motif of 'Before Departure' acts as a very well-judged relief-giver and palate/palette-cleanser. Again, there's that folky, Vaughan-Williams/Britten-esque quality.

PJH's use of the upper reaches of her vocal range is very effective, throughout the album. But when I got to the final stages of 'The Mountain' (the album's closing track), I was amazed. The unrooted, meandering character of the early stages of the song gives way to an extraordinary (and I don't use the word lightly) collage of arpeggios, top-of-range and soaring vocals. This is brilliant - not over-the-top - for two reasons: it does not drag or become 'epic'; and the new vocal quality is underpinned - more, it is justified - by an accompanying shift into new harmonic territories, with unexpected and extreme key-changes (or key-shifts, perhaps) appearing in sudden abundance. Without this harmonic adventurousness, the vocals might seem gratuitous; with them, the result is an inspired album-closer.

To return to my opening comments on the album artwork: after you've listened to the disc, you realise how beautifully the packaging design mirrors the music itself. Somewhat stark, spartan, poised - reined back, almost ... But simultaneously earthy, textured, organic and 'real'. Despite all the 'whiteness', there's also a warmth to the artwork (heightened magenta and yellow, at the expense of cold blue tones) that emulates the warmth of the album's acoustic instrumentation.

Aesthetically, this is a brilliant album, on first impressions.

Tom

"Cogwheel Dogs":http://www.cogwheeldogs.com

Comments (8)

  1. Girlcrawl says Exceptional review! Merci.
    Permalink posted 09/26/2007
  2. cogwheeldogs says Hi Girlcrawl... And thanks very much...
    Permalink posted 09/26/2007
  3. multivitamin says Hit her with a hammer Teeth smashed in Red tongue twitching Look inside her skeleton My fingers sting Where I feel your fingers have been Ghostly fingers Moving my limbs ( when it comes to atmosphere and intensity, PJ's lyrics are simply divine )
    Permalink posted 10/04/2007
  4. Bartleby says It's funny and quite apt that an album called "White Chalk" is so full of colours. Colours in the chords, colours in the artwork, colours in the lyrics also, I'm sure. Speaking a which, as multivitamin reminds us, Ms Harvey has always considered herself first and foremost a lyricist. Thank you for so evocatively sharing (explaining) her aesthetics to us.
    Permalink posted 10/06/2007
  5. cogwheeldogs says Yes, very interesting, and, as you say, apt. White as a combination (balanced) of all colours ... And the lyrics are powerful, indeed. I always find it harder to focus on lyrics than on music, personally (for all artists, that is, not specifically PJH). I think, myself, that I find PJ Harvey's lyrics, even so, slightly less remarkable than her music. But that's not to detract from them -- rather, to emphasise the extent to which I admire the music. Anyway, thanks (both Bartleby and Multivitamin) for the comments. I *really* like the 'interactive, multi-faceted' review syndrome that this fine site facilitates...
    Permalink posted 10/06/2007
  6. artificialflower says i enjoyed your review very much. i've been scouring the net and read quite a few, but your critique is by far the best. *hangs head in shame* there isn't a single britten, williams or amos track in my eclectic record collection. i will try to correct that.
    Permalink posted 10/09/2007
  7. hazydevil says Having just ordered 'White Chalk' online yesterday, you've only managed to heighten my anticipation. Thanks for the great review!
    Permalink posted 10/09/2007
  8. david hyman says well done
    Permalink posted 10/24/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved