WHERE THE HOKEY POKEY "IS" WHAT IT'S ALL ABOUT

Legitimation Generation

Posted about 1 year ago
Back when Kronos Quartet released their cover - if you can call it that, given the context - of Jimi Hendrix's "Purple Haze," I was excited. Raised on classical music, in a household where my father didn't want me to play rock on his turntable because the beat would "hurt the needle," I welcomed the opportunity to declare, "If it's good enough for a world-famous string quartet, it should be good enough for you." Subsequently, however, I went on to do a lot of thinking, informed by the sort of cultural theory - the work of Pierre Bourdieu, for example - that scholars in the humanities and social sciences consume, that made me rethink my initial thoughts on the matter. At first I railed at the idea that rock music needed to be legitimated in that manner. Then I began to realize that this legitimation was largely bound to the aging of the Baby Boomer generation, which, as my friend Steven - "Masoo" here on MOG - has ably pointed out, is the generation that has consistently wanted to have its widening wealth and waistlines without losing the aura of youth culture, claiming rock for its own long into middle age and now even retirement.From this perspective, the Kronos Quartet cover of "Purple Haze" shouldn't be regarded as a means of legitimating classic rock by dressing it in the garb of classical music, but of reducing all culture to the common denominator of the Baby Boomer mindset, in which everything goes, provided that its routed through the circuit of collective narcissism. Now that I'm middle-aged myself, I'm trying to figure out, as a member of "Generation X," what sorts of practices I might be engaged in that achieve an analogous effect. I doubt whether I will be able to forestall my participation in them and am not even sure whether it would make sense to try. But I'm still a believer in the value of self-awareness for its own sake - perhaps that's where the imprimatur of my generation leaves the most inky blotches - and would therefore like to know what I'm doing to make myself feel like culture centers on people like me.

Comments (4)

  1. Masoo says To some extent, boomers bypass the notion of legitimation by pretending they don't participate in it. As I've argued elsewhere, when we were kids, the generation gap was assumed to exist. Then, as we became parents, our self-described cool factor meant that we tried to co-opt the next generation, as if we owned youth and rebellion. If rock and roll was the art form of youthful rebellion, and if it was also "our" artform, its continued importance meant we were still youthful and rebellious, leaving subsequent generations with nothing against which they could rebel. Didn't work, of course. Talk about legitimation ... rap music was a slap in the face to all those boomers who thought they had it figured out, and we resorted to the same, lame "it's not music" tirades our parents had offered about rock and roll. Then hip-hop took over as the primary form of youth culture, leaving rock and roll to the John Mellencamps of the world. Your generation needs to legitimate itself because my generation refuses to accept your existence. Y'all should just tell us to fuck off :-).
    Permalink posted 12/14/2007
  2. ZeppoNoir says Well I guess I was confused! I was getting the Brodsky Quartet and the Kronos Quartet mixed up these past few years. "Egg on my face.":http://mog.com/ZeppoNoir/blog_post/130169#comments
    Permalink posted 12/14/2007
  3. ZeppoNoir says BYW...thanks for the post. Was good to hear that again. :-)
    Permalink posted 12/14/2007
  4. cbertsch says Thanks for the comments, Masoo and ZeppoNoir. I do like the Kronos Quartet version, even if it makes me think too hard
    Permalink posted 12/14/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved

Join MOG Today. It's Free.

We hate spam even more than you do. We will NOT sell your email address.

Pick a good one! Screen name can't be changed.

Must be at least six characters.

For Musicians
Cancel

Already A Mogger?