MUSIC CHATTER AND MATTER

Get Lucky (no, not the Loverboy album)

Posted about 1 year ago
My critical faculties are temporarily out of service. They have been completely undone by the new Nada Surf album, Lucky.I think they wanted to tell you something about how you can really forget their annoying hit "Popular" of 12 years ago, and something else about how this is a better Teenage Fanclub record than Teenage Fanclub has ever recorded. (And both I and my critical faculties like Teenage Fanclub a lot.)My critical faculties were trying to get some distance from the music so as to offer a dispassionate appraisal of this album. But there's nothing dispassionate about my response to this record. I simply love it. For one thing, it's rare that a record is as beautiful as this one. We value a lot of things in popular music: "catchy," "rockin'" "funky" "danceable"; but "beautiful" seldom makes the list. The sound is lush and complex, and the album is crammed to the edges with beauty: melodies, harmonies, backing vocals, cello parts - many tracks are so pretty it almost hurts to listen to them. Even now, as I make swoony goo-goo eyes at my computer while I type this and "See These Bones" plays, I'm getting some very strange looks from my fellow coffee shop patrons. But this is what love does: it makes you ridiculous. (When I reread this in six months, I'm sure I'll be cringing at my earnestness; but, for now, I'm going irony free.)Of course, the music is only half the story; the lyrics hit me where I live--in that strange bittersweet zone where joy and sadness meet. The album is packed with images of death, loss, and sadness: "just like we are, you'll be dust," "ice is growing on the wings," "everyone's got to leave their love sometime." But this is no mopefest; it's catchy, it rocks, and it proves, in an unassuming, unpretentious way that popular art and great art can be the same thing.

Comments (8)

  1. contrabandwidth says Talk about a comeback, Nada Surf's is over 12 years in the making. The novelty of "Popular" turned me off giving their music a serious listen, unfortunately. A couple years ago one of my friends played _Let Go_ for me and I was blown away. I wasn't sure how this was the same group, but all the things you mentioned about this album, applied to that one too. I couldn't believe they were still around, and that no one was talking about them, because that album was really good. Thanks for the review, and I'm definitely gonna keep my eye out for this one.
    Permalink posted 02/07/2008
  2. dachmo says I've been hearing way too much about Nada Surf lately, the only thing I know from the band is that song "popular" which, unlike most people, I haven't heard enough to start to hate. I'll push them to the top of my to get list, thanks.
    Permalink posted 02/07/2008
  3. Jonh Ingham says Oooh I like this! They're one of those bands that's easy to know about without knowing. It reminds me of all the good things about 90s indie pop with none of the bad bits. God that sounds like faint praise but I'm putting this on my list of Things I Must Get.
    Permalink posted 02/08/2008
  4. dermahrk says You had me at "Teenage Fanclub". So I listened, and I can't hear that connection, but I have to agree that this is great stuff. I too have to check them out further now that I've heard more than the name.
    Permalink posted 02/08/2008
  5. HelenMarie says I love your descriptions (esp. the 2 ending para's). "But this is what love does: it makes you ridiculous. (When I reread this in six months, I'm sure I'll be cringing at my earnestness; but, for now, I'm going irony free.)" Ha! So true! Love this song. (and I highly value beauty in music) Thanks!
    Permalink posted 02/08/2008
  6. scotfree says picked this up, based on your most excellent review, and It's just as tasty as your word. I think I was teetering on the sadness side of that bittersweet zone, 'cause I had to pause after "Beautiful Beat" to regain composure. diving back in...thanks!
    Permalink posted 02/09/2008
  7. david hyman says wow. my good friend is friends with these guys. i should get them to do something on mog.
    Permalink posted 02/11/2008
  8. dana says Dave's good-friend-who-knows-these-guys here. It is so good to see Nada Surf getting the love and props they deserve. I used to see them play at the Bond St. Cafe in NYC in 1991 (pre-Popular). But they weren't Nada Surf back then...they were called Because Because Because (little known fact). By '95ish they were calling themselves Nada Surf and I saw them debut Popular at a show at CBGBs. It had hit written all over it. About 10 years passed and I'd listen to a song here or there. Then I went to see them play the Berkeley Community Theater last year and--holy shit--realized they have become one of the best pop bands out there. Such great musicianship. And Matthew Caws' (a fellow MOGGER) voice is clear and beautiful. Was lucky enough to see them again a few weeks ago playing an unplugged set at Cafe du Nord in SF. They just keep getting better and better. Looking forward to catching their upcoming show at the Fillmore. Highly recommend checking them out live.
    Permalink posted 02/20/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved