WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

The Old Man Down The Road

Posted over 2 years ago
John Fogerty fronted the best American band of the 1960's. (You could make a really good case for Sly and the Family Stone, but otherwise, there's not really any serious competition. The Band? When you can't fill a greatest hits album with good songs, you're in trouble. The Byrds? Cloying! The Grateful Dead? Are you high? Actually, I suppose if you think the Dead are the best American band of the 60's, it's very likely that you actually are high, or that you soon will be. Enjoy!)This being the case, it's difficult to judge a new John Fogerty album without measuring it against his amazing body of work with CCR. That would be pretty unfair, but here's John pretty much daring us to do that by calling his new album "Revival."Revival is not as good as Willy and the Poor Boys, but it is a damn good record. A surprisingly good record. What's especially gratifying about this is that Fogerty hasn't followed the blueprint for how a legendary artist makes a stab at relevance: get a bunch of younger guest stars with more fans and less talent than you, mix until platinum. Instead, he's just come out alone and made a John Fogerty record.It starts inauspiciously with a rather tepid song called "Don't You Wish It Was True." Aha, I thought upon hearing this. Like so many of his peers, Fogerty is content to slide into a comfortable senescence and release pleasant, forgettable music from time to time. (Well, Van Morrison has slid into grumpy senescence, but you know what I mean.)Fortunately, the rest of the record dispels this impression pretty quickly. Fogerty uncorks some top-notch country songs: "River is Waiting" is the kind of beautiful song we shouldn't be surprised to hear from the guy who gave us "Lodi" and "Wrote a Song For Everyone." Even "Broken Down Cowboy" is a fantastic song, and I am predisposed to hate songs comparing singers to cowboys, having been damaged in my youth by "Desperado" and "Wanted Dead or Alive." I guess I shouldn't be surprised to find angry, rockin' commentary on the current political situation from the guy who wrote "Fortunate Son" (still great, still relevant), but it's a bracing surprise to hear the anti-war, anti-Bush songs "Long Dark Night" (kind of a companion to "Bad Moon Rising") and "I Can't Take it No More." Even "Gunslinger" is a pretty obvious allegory as Fogerty imagines himself in an old west town longing for somebody to show up and set things right.What shocked me about this is not that Fogerty is writing songs like this, it's that he's one of the only people doing it. Where the hell are the younger musicians? Well, that's probably another post, but for right now, Fogerty is back and he's pissed, and it sounds great.You can sing blues and country songs pretty much forever, but a lot of older performers have trouble rocking convincingly. No trouble here. "Longshot" and "Somebody Help Me" and "I Can't Take it No More" all cook like classic Creedence.Revival isn't the complete career reinvention that American Recordings was for Johnny Cash, but it's similarly stunning. Here's a guy that I and probably many other people had long written off coming back strong to remind us that he's not only still here, he's still damn good at what he does.

Comments (15)

  1. Augusts1 says Um, as much as I love CCR(hell I grew up listening to them since my dad loved 'em) I wouldn't call them the best American band. Hendrix & The Doors are right up there with them. Even though I'm not a huge fan of either, those are the two that popped into my head that are legends who rival CCR. I wholeheartedly agree w/you on the Grateful Dead though, lol!
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  2. Bartleby says I'm a big CCR fan and sometimes it saddens me to think of their past brilliancy. But one should not consider Fogerty's solo efforts in contrast with the past. The two are separate entities. The hardest part is to differentiate the two. I must say it's more than I can do unfortunately. (Your review does it for me though)
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  3. deadmandeadman says I almost didn't get past the first pargraph. Are YOU high? The Band (+Dylan) were playing loud intelligent articulate rock n roll in 1966. From 67-75 there was no American band worthy to be roadies for the Band. CCR were great, don't get me wrong, but musicaly they were fairly basic. They had a consistantly populist sound that recalls some of the finer points of country/rock. The Band was making a fuller, richer, more complex brand of Americana music with roots in the mississippi mud, in the dancehalls and barrooms, in the brothels of America. They also exhibited an affinity for the Motown Sound and Rhythm & Blues in general. CCR was essentially John Fogarty and whoever he allowed to ride his coattails. He had the chops to pull it off for a while, too. But his music is, as I say, more basic, more conventional than The Band's.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  4. brendanhalpin says Ah, I knew folks wouldn't let me get away with a provocative statement like that unchallenged. Hendrix was brilliant, but I just don't think his songwriting was as good as his playing. The Doors never did it for me. I like the pop songs--"Touch Me" is great, but I just never bought Morrison's (or as I like to call him, J. Mo) lyrics on the other stuff. And the keyboard drives me nuts. Maybe because Manzarek practically ruined the first X album with it. I brought up The Band, but I think we can sidestep the argument because they were 4/5 Canadian.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  5. deadmandeadman says "I brought up The Band, but I think we can sidestep the argument because they were 4/5 Canadian." Are you a Clinton?
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  6. Iren says I don't know.... really Fire with Fire is a good tune, but the Goliwogs don't really compare to The Sonics, The Wailers, THe 13th Floor Elevators, and that's not even mentioning The MC5 or The Stooges... wait you were talking about CCR.. A lot of great tunes, and really better than any of the bands you mentioned... but really better than The Stalk Forrest Group?? or The Spiders (from LA, or was it Tempe?) I'm not sure... still when ever I think of CCR I think of the Dude.....
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  7. Jonh Ingham says If you want to really get your CCR rocks off go to Wolfganag's Vault and look up their gig from the closing of Winterland or Fillmore West (I forget which). It's got everything you're writing about. And then some.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  8. brendanhalpin says Hmmmm...am I a Clinton? I guess that depends on what the definition of am is.
    Permalink posted 11/13/2007
  9. extraordinarypoems says Great tune.
    Permalink posted 11/13/2007
  10. deadmandeadman says Hmmmm…am I a Clinton? I guess that depends on what the definition of am is. Great answer
    Permalink posted 11/13/2007
  11. Michael Goldberg says You know I don't think there is one band that is the greatest American band. CCR were awesome, but the first three albums by The Band are classic and I don't care if what part of North American they were born in. Don't write off the Byrds. So many great songs on the first five or so albums. The Lovin' Spoonful always get neglected but their first three albums are masterpieces. The Grateful Dead's first four or so albums are very strong. The Velvet Underground were right up there. So were The Doors and Hendrix and X's first two or three albums are genius. Television, Talking Heads, Patti Smith Group, Nirvana, Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band... And that's just off the top of my head.
    Permalink posted 11/14/2007
  12. Cody B says Brendan, I love the way you crash around a china shop..no mater who you am talking about. What's all this hub bub abot that Canadian band, The Band. Not that you'd give a damn! but here's "A The Band Vs.The Dead debate":http://mog.com/Cody_B/blog_post/36935
    Permalink posted 11/15/2007
  13. brendanhalpin says The funny thing is, I actually like The Band. I saw them in 84 or 85 without Robbie Robertson opening for Crosby Stills and Nash, and they completely blew CS&N off the stage. Maybe not that hard to do, but I almost felt bad for CS&N. The Band closed with "The Weight," and to go from that to "Love the One You're With," well...it hardly seemed fair. But for all that, The Band seem like one of those, uh, bands that ultimately inspire more respect than affection, which I think your Band vs. Dead debate shows. I do like a couple of Dead songs: "Friend of the Devil," "Ripple," um...I might be done. But having been a teen in the 80's, I really hated the way they marketed this phony nostalgia to my peers who got swept up in this whole tie-dye thing and walked around high talking about how today's music was shit and they had been born too late. Also I met this really cute deadhead girl once who had no interest in dating me. I guess that's not Jerry's fault, but I kinda hold it against him anyway.
    Permalink posted 11/15/2007
  14. tekla says "What shocked me about this is not that Fogerty is writing songs like this, it’s that he’s one of the only people doing it. Where the hell are the younger musicians?" Well in case you missed the last Bruce Springsteen record he was pretty much anti-war too. And, even the Boss can't get it played on the radio these days. Despite that it went to number one. The younger bands ARE doing this stuff, its just that the corporate radio people like Clear Channel keep it off the radio so you are not hearing it.
    Permalink posted 11/18/2007
  15. avenustylee says Great post.Cool song. At least he doesn't seem to be gettin' soft in his old age. :)
    Permalink posted 11/19/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved