Analysis Of O.A.R.'s "Shattered" Lyrics

I got my first request! Jeff Baker asked to hear my thoughts on the song "Shattered" by O.A.R.. I replied to him that it is interesting he brought this song up because the song intrigued me as well.

Jeff wrote an in depth analysis of the meaning of the lyrics to "Shattered" in his post titled "Is It A Love Song?". I strongly urge you to go read his post. I feel that he pegged the meaning of this song dead on. I will add my thoughts about the song now, so come back here to read them after you visit Jeff's post.

To me, this song is about a bad and unhealthy relationship. I agree with Jeff that it is not about love. It is about uncertainty and fear. The relationship provides a security blanket for him. He knows what to expect from it and to him, that is better than the unknown.

While he realizes that he is better off without the relationship, he allows himself to go back to it because it has become his safety net. He longs to try life on his own and let himself discover healthier and happier relationships. However, his need for something familiar drives him back to where he should not be. Quite possibly, it is even a form of self punishment for subconscious feelings of guilt.

The overall theme of "Shattered" reminds me of another song. This song is a little darker but I think it is related to the concept. It is called "Cover Me" by Candelbox. In this song, he basically loathes his partner but uses her for "shelter from the storm". Unfortunately, I think there are far too many relationships just like that.

What are your thoughts on the song? Jeff mentioned that a lot of people disagreed with his thoughts and that they DO think it is a love song (in a positive way). Please comment with your analysis of "Shattered".

(Image courtesy of FreeFoto.com)



"Shattered" by O.A.R.




"Cover Me" by Candelbox