AMG Review of Best of Judy Garland: 20th Century Masters

Stephen Thomas Erlewine
All Music Guide

Like any record company worth their salt, MCA knows a good gimmick when they see it, and when the millennium came around...well, the 20th Century Masters -- The Millennium Collection wasn't too far behind. Supposedly, the millennium is a momentous occasion, but it's hard to feel that way when it's used as another excuse to turn out a budget-line series. But apart from the presumptuous title, 20th Century Masters -- The Millennium Collection turns out to be a very good budget-line series. True, it's impossible for any of these brief collections to be definitive, but they're nevertheless solid samplers that don't feature a bad song in the bunch. For example, take Judy Garland's 20th Century volume -- it's an irresistible 12-song summary of her Decca years. There may be a couple of noteworthy songs missing, but many of her best-known songs for the label are here, including "Over the Rainbow," "I Got Rhythm," "Meet Me in St. Louis," "Embraceable You," "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas," "But Not for Me," "Swanee," "The Trolley Song" and "On the Atchison, Topeka and the Santa Fe." Serious fans will want something more extensive, but this is an excellent introduction for neophytes and a great sampler for casual fans, considering its length and price. That doesn't erase the ridiculousness of the series title, but the silliness is excusable when the music and the collections are good.