Echoes 2001: A Pink Floyd Odyssey

Posted over 5 years ago
I have heard and seen "Dark Side of the Wizard of Oz." Same holds true for "Alice in the Wall-derland." Trust me, they both pale in comparison to the best Pink Floyd syncronization ever. Yes, you can stretch the lyrics so they seem analagous to the action on screen; but that is the mind's interpretation, because words have numerous meanings, especially when strung into a poetic sentance. The gauge of syncronicity should lie in the music itself, untouched and in a way that is less open to interpretation. To that end let me point out that Dark Side runs out in the middle of Wizard of Oz; and to make The Wall work with Alice in Wonderland, you have to shave the album. There is no existant synchronicity that would point to deliberate action on Pink Floyd's part.So let me challenge you to try this one for size. Pull out your CD "Meddle" (my favorite by Pink Floyd) and rent a copy of 2001: A Space Odyssey. The movie is divided up into different "acts." The final act, "Jupiter and Beyond," is repleate with the Oscar-winning special effects that were groundbreaking at the time - and are still, in most places, pretty fresh today. There is not one spoken word throughout this 23 minute, 25 second act. Instead, the silence is only broken by a gawdawful "avante guarde" modern operatic travesty of ascending voices that willfully hurts the ears. Who knows what Kubrick was thinking, but this has to be one of the worst scores in one of the best movies ever.Along comes Echoes, a song only 3 seconds longer than "Jupiter and Beyond."Now the length of time may be almost synchronous, but there is much more."Jupiter and Beyond" is presented in a series of visual themes... the first is outer space; the second is one very colorful special effects extraveganda that is homogenous, edited only with flashes of the astronaut's eyes (probably the most memorable part of this act); the third another special effects show that is made of short clips done with all kinds of nifty optical effects and in-camera genious, then edited together; the fourth is false-color shots of mountains, oceans and iceburgs that was meant to convey an alien planet's surface; the fifth is a small room that the main character, David Bowman, ages in until he is on his deathbed; and the final theme is back into outer space.So what does this have to do with Echoes and synchronicity? Well, Echoes is comprised of six thematic parts as well, which are practically syncronous in segue with the film's. Most notably, the midsection of the song has no music, but the members of Pink Floys make crazy, animal-like shreaks and howls - sounds that might evoke some prehistoric or alien creature. This section begins as the false-color images start to play out, and segues back to psychedelic music as Kubrick's movie cuts from those images to David Bowman shaking and sweating in his capsule. So you are hearing haunting, alien cries against an filmic alien land. This is perhaps the most promenent synchronicity, because the images and the sound work so well together and change up at the same time. But this holds true of all thematic segues in the music and the movie.So what does this mean? There are two ways to think about it. Either it is pure chance... or maybe the boys in Floyd decided they couldn't stand the Kubrick soundtrack and were inspired to make their own, more listenable version. Although that certainly comes to mind when you see how much like a true soundtrack it is, synchronous to nearly the second with the themes and the entire act, I will err on the side of caution and say it is just happy coincidence. So how do you do it? Simple... At the moment the title "Jupiter and Beyond" disappears, hit play so you hear the first piano "clink" right there. Then just watch the next twenty three and half minutes of the movie. And then tell me you don't feel shivers run up your spine when the final image of the star-child fades to black as the music fades away with haunting precision.Go on, give it a try. And let me know what you think.

Comments (8)

  1. helmar says I've known about this one for a long time. I'm absolutely positive that Pink Floyd composed Echoes to the 3rd act of 2001. Its far too perfectly synched to be a coincidence. Im a film editor and I know all about the random-track-placed-under-random-assemblage-of-footage-always-creates-amazing-synchronicities phenomenon. The Wizard of Oz/Darkside seems to fit this category better, although I wouldn't be surprised to find Pink composed for that to. No, 2001 Act3/Echoes is 100% planned from the start. Its really well done too, I actually prefer it to the original audio track.
    Permalink posted 07/26/2006
  2. helmar says that's ALWAYS-CREATES-AMAZING-SYNCHRONICITIES phenomenon. Thank you html.
    Permalink posted 07/26/2006
  3. helmar says The part that really sold it for me, besides the weird non-music part when he's fly over the land space timing out perfectly, is the moment when the old Kier Dullea turns around and the young realizes he's lookign at himself, the music does something that scores the moment perfectly. Its a goose bump moment.
    Permalink posted 07/26/2006
  4. Whoohaha says I just came across this idea a couple of weeks ago (right after Sid's death). A co-worker and I were discussing the Dark Side of Oz, when he mentioned the 2001/Echoes synchro. So, being the huge Floyd fan, I decided to rent it and try it out. From what I understand Kubrick wanted Pink Floyd to produce the score for 2001 from the get go, but something happened (yada, yada, yada) it didn’t work out. And with all synchros, it is never perfect the first time around. Well, after a few runs through, I must admit that it is kind of cool. Just when I didn’t think I had it just right something would time in perfectly. But all in all, it is in no way as good as Dark Side of Oz. Sorry, but if and when you get that synched up properly with the Wizard of Oz, it blows your mind away. From the bending of the tornado in the great gig in the sky, to the lyrics matching the sequences that are on the screen, when you get it right, it is money (no pun intended there).
    Permalink posted 07/26/2006
  5. Parker catalano says The only thing is that there totally are lyrics in echoes. Kick ass lyrics at that, but I will definitely try this because that could be my favorite Kubrick flick as well as my favorite Floyd song.
    Permalink posted 07/26/2006
  6. Heli0tr0pe says yes indeedy Sir Sef - the "Wizard of Oz" thing never really made sense to me anyway, since the film is like 100 minutes long or so, and "Dark Side" is about what, 42, 43 minutes? so you're meant to restart the album again, and then yet another time but only for like 15 minutes until the movie ends? feh. however, i could TOTALLY see the Floyd recording "Echoes" at Abbey Road while a big-ass screen overhead showed that last segment of "2001"...that just seems like something they would really go for. right? so there ya have it - full and complete agreement! (or agreeance, if you're Fred Durst.) i therefore decree: you can now have your pudding without having eaten your meat!!!
    Permalink posted 07/27/2006
  7. Jorobot says Pretty tight, and in my head I can def. imagine these going together. Floyd and Kubrick is kind of a match made in heaven. I have to disagree with you about the original score, though, which is groundbreaking itself and kind of brilliant. Gyorgy Ligeti is the composer, who also scored The Shining and Eyes Wide Shut. He was the first guy to apply the electronic breakthroughs of guys like K. Stockhausen to orchestral music, and created the concept of micropolyphony, chords that slowly shift into one another. His 2001 work still perfectly evokes for me the intense anxiety of hurtling through time and space, with that harmonically melting choir of voices, and I think it fits the scene perfectly, though in a very different way than Echoes does.
    Permalink posted 08/07/2006
  8. ROCKNROLLPIMP1 says kick ass i'm gonna do this tonight!!!
    Permalink posted 08/12/2006

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved