MELT-PROOF AND SCRATCH-RESISTANT

Professor Puff's: "Costello Music" by The Fratellis

Posted over 2 years ago
If you're like me, and I have a eerie feeling you probably are to some extent, you're half annoyed, half intrigued by the near constant flow of new post-punk pub bands who quantify themselves with the definite article "The" prefixing the noun of their name. The Strokes, The View, The Vines, The Bravery, The Futureheads, The Hives, The Killers, The Sounds, The Rapture, The Raveonettes....etc, etc, into infinity. Now this naming scheme is tried and true, I mean it basically went to the same pre-school as Rock itself, and I've no real problem with it aside from it's trendiness and current saturation. I liken it to the trend of the 90's where your band name was a noun followed by a random number (Blink 182, Eve 6, Sum 41, Stroke 9, et. al.) and it can wear a person out. Quickly. However the ubiquitous "The" is not now, nor has it ever been, a deal breaker for me to listen to a band. Neither is their proverbial joy-ride on the pub-shoo-wop bandwagon. Hence when the iPod commercial came out with the catchy "ba-da-bap-ba-da-da-das" of "Flathead" by The Fratellis I found it honestly groovy. Yes they borrow from every soccer hooligan band with big black stomping boots ever, yes they sound like a lot of other bands out there at the moment but I hold them to the same standard I hold bands like Wolfmother and Interpol to; sure there were bands that did that sound historically and classically better, but this specific music is still "new". I mean if Interpol had released Joy Division's "Unknown Pleasures" in it's entirety then I could fault them for not being original, but the fact is no matter what they borrowed from their mentors they still put out unique tracks. So the Fratellis may have borrowed their sound from artists as distant as Elvis recent as Arctic Monkeys but they still put out an album of 12 original songs that they wrote all by themselves. And that's what this album is; 12 songs that sound like a lot of other music out there at the moment. If you put The Futureheads, Arctic Monkeys, The View and The Fratellis in a playlist and shuffled them while you were doing your laundry I don't think you'd ever notice the shift between bands. Not that their music is band, but it's just more of the same. So much of the same in fact that I won't even go into the specifics of this album track by track. Puffmagic gives The Fratellis 3.5 out of 5 Rob Gordons

Comments (14)

  1. kaluss says i've never really thought of it that way....and now....i can't get away from it and i am annoyed too. ugh!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  2. theyouthcard says Although I dont like them on the basis of "the drummer looks like he would smell of pee and vomit" they have been growing on me A LOT lately, firstly the iPod ad which really made me sit up and go "cool" when I heard the song and "Bollocks" when I found out it was them, secondly they have a new video/song out now and its in the "Hot Fuzz" movie this annoyed me too but the bastarding thing has got me feeling something for it in the pit of me gullet (sp?) Anyways! Thank you for the review and I may just download the album (dont like them enough just yet to pay for it), I feel I can trust your opinion a little more than if you were from Europe cos over here we are being oversaturated with all those bands you mentioned above and being told they are the BEST THING EVER so instead of having to deal with all of them Ive been skipping the lot, so thanks once again!!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  3. Puffmagic says No problem. I do like the album, it's catchy, but again, it's still just another 'tater in the Big Pile O' 'Taters.
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  4. Anna says You're strict :(
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  5. Puffmagic says I'm strict? Get online and type that to my face Bananna!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  6. Anna says I'm trying to get on line and tell you off right now, daddy-O!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  7. Puffmagic says Bring it on! Bring it ON! Wait, I didn't really trash this album, what are we fighting about?
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  8. Anna says Haha Because it's fun. And because I wanted a 7+ puffy rating!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  9. Puffmagic says Sorry, just could let go of that extra half a point. Maybe next time.
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  10. chucky says Is it bad that I want to check out all of the artists in that laundry playlist? Hell, I figure if I like one, I'd like them all and I'd have four times the music. Haha.
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  11. LyricalRevolution says hooray for The Fratellis!!!
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  12. 1234chainsaw says Puffy did good, especially considering that he could have written almost exactly what he wrote even if the topic had been, say, Arctic Monkeys or The Rakes or The Rifles instead of The Fratellis. That's a rather nice achievement, given the post's main thrust . . .
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  13. tybees says Thanks for telling me what to think, I was having a really hard time trying to figure it out on my own :)
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007
  14. lemontwist says Hahahahaha, Puff, I love this post.
    Permalink posted 02/20/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved