AT 11 24/7
Pseudo Cyborg
Pseudo Cyborg of Rapscallion The Ne'er-Do-Well, Erased Files

"What a botheration!"

Posted over 2 years ago
  • Artist:
    Bob Marley & The Wailers
  • Album:
    Rasta Revolution
  • Track:
    Mr. Brown

Yesterday I was going through my library at work—looking for something fresh—when I stumbled on a Mojo compilation I got from a friend, Mojo Presents: Trojan Explosion. The track titles were all present, but the artists were all credited as "Various". I remembered I had tried looking this information up before a couple years ago, but my search was fruitless. Yesterday, however, I found both the cover artwork and a proper tracklisting.

Happy days are here again.

I gave it a couple listens yesterday and nearly kicked my own ass for not doing so sooner. Every track is phoenomenal.

On the way to work today, I decided to give it another listen. The first track, "Mr. Brown" by Bob Marley And The Wailers, is mixed uniquely and definitely evident when listening on headphones. Listening to it yesterday my curiosity was stirred but I was too deep in work to really give it proper thought. This morning, however, something dawned on me.

This song wasn't mixed with the stereo channels meant for right and left, they were meant for front and rear.

I've yet to give this a go on proper speakers that I can place accordingly, but I can definitely hear it in my mind. The right channel is definitely the front channel, bright with mids and highs and attack from the lows. The left channel is filled with the lower frequency, almost like a sub channel. Both have the vocals which were panned "center".

My mind's ear is dying to get home and give this a go, although I'm almost certain this would work.

The only question I'm left with is whether or not this was intentional, an experiment in "surround sound". It would be very amazing if it were.

Comments (11)

  1. Spike says God knows what they were thinking, or if they were thinking. I have a few cuts like that, where bass was left and treble right, or visa-versa, and it is not ideal. But your take on it, that is, treble front, bass rear, is brilliant. I'll have to try it out. Another solution would be mono. Speaking of mono, I remember reading an interview with Brian Wilson in a late 60s copy of Crawdaddy magazine, in which Brian Wilson said that mono is the greatest, and the worshipful interviewer said yes mono must be the greatest. Later I read that Brian Wilson is deaf in one ear.
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  2. Pseudo Cyborg says Well, I know in a lot of early stereo tracks people didn't really know what to do with the technology. In some ways it's quaint hearing stuff hard panned either left or right... but most of the time it's just annoying as all living hell. Given the option, I prefer those early tracks as mono, as you pointed out. I had never thought of listening to it this way before, but this song in particular... it just sounds like it was meant to be front/rear vs right/left. Definitely give it a listen and I'm sure you'll hear that as a possible intention as well. It seriously blew my pre-coffee mind this morning. ROFLMAO Oh man, I love Brian Wilson. That's one of the best anecdotes I've heard about him ever.
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  3. Kate says I emailed your question to my dad, I think he just may know the answer. I'll get back to you.
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  4. Pseudo Cyborg says Awesometacular! Thanks, Kate.
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  5. Kate says Okay, according to my dad, Mojo must have messed with the track, because the original version of Mr. Brown was a straight ahead stereo mix done by Lee Scratch Perry in 1970. Freaky!
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  6. Pseudo Cyborg says Really?!!?! Summonabish! Hmm. I've got it uploaded on Multiply, but here's a link for those not registered who'd like to hear. [Right-click/Control-click to save file.]
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  7. Pseudo Cyborg says Well I'll be. I found a sample of the album track online and, yes, it's a straight-ahead stereo mix. Peculiar.
    Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  8. Pseudo Cyborg says I ventured off onto Trojan Records’ website to see if I could find some more information. I couldn’t find much of anything except for a small clip on their product information page for a Permalink posted 12/08/2006
  9. Pseudo Cyborg says Sure enough, placing the right channel in front and the left channel behind creates a sort of surround-sound effect. Very cool, intentional or not.
    Permalink posted 12/12/2006
  10. Spike says As I was adjusting the sound of my car sound system today, it occured to me that fact (which I've known for years) that the rear speakers have better bass than the front speakers is an example of your idea.
    Permalink posted 12/15/2006
  11. Pseudo Cyborg says You're absolutely right. I hadn't even thought of that, either. I'm really starting to wonder if this "simple" question wasn't quite so. lol
    Permalink posted 12/15/2006

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved

Join MOG Today. It's Free.

We hate spam even more than you do. We will NOT sell your email address.

Pick a good one! Screen name can't be changed.

Must be at least six characters.

For Musicians
Cancel

Already A Mogger?