WHERE THE HOKEY POKEY "IS" WHAT IT'S ALL ABOUT

The Raconteurs - Live - A Classic Rock Juggernaut

Posted about 1 year ago
My friends, who have superb taste, were turning to me during and after this show saying things like, "This is the best classic rock show I've ever seen." I try to stay away from such extremes, but I am hard pressed to disagree, at least for a modern era rock band. But what do I mean by this? I mean total vocal, guitar, and rhythm section mastery, combined with perfectly crafted, simple yet intricate songs, that take you on a journey replete with psychologically poignant lyrics, filled with all out big rock moments and intimate, trippy ones too. Oh yeah, and immaculate taste.That last one is certainly subjective, but there were moments reminiscent of The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Cheap Trick, ELP, Queen, King Crimson, even Skynnard. And too many garage bands to even get into. And not obvious rip off moments. This band is original, at least as much as that's possible in rock. At one point I turned to my friend and commented on the Garage Rock meets Sweet vibe going on; a sexy, raunchy, boogie rock thing with serious 70's vocal harmony largess as the cherry on top. Brendan has really stepped into this role. Doing more guitar soloing, and singing his ass off. Both he and Jack were in terrific voice and just killed it. It was Brendan's voice at points that was hitting me like Robin Zander, thus the Cheap Trick comparison.But what we're talking about here is a band that looks the part, sounds the part, writes the part, and fucking nails it with pure American/British style and swagger, combined with Midwestern humility. That formula is rock n roll gold as far as I'm concerned. This was an arena show. That band was way larger than the room, and they and everyone there knew it. I'm just glad I got a chance to see it in such a small venue.But, I still have two complaints (and how could I not complain as a neurotic, Jewish, New Yorker?). Bassist Jack Lawrence should sing more. He sounded really pretty and strong. And his vocal blend with the hired gun keyboard, violin, tambourine guy was spot on. Coulda used more of that. And my friend and I felt bad for the utility guy as he added so much value and yet was not allowed to take a bow with the band at the end of the show. Simply uncouth if you ask me. Okay fine, he is not an original member or maybe not even on the studio record, I don't know, but he was damn good and part of the live show, so treat him as such. But I digress.I am one of those guys who has always seen the immensely obvious Jack White talent but was never fully into The White Stripes. I always thought, I want to hear this guy in a band. And that first Raconteurs record was good, but still sounded like a recording project. This one just blows it out of the water. These guys found their sound on the road in an organic fashion and it is now firing on all cylinders. And they've screwed with the tunes off the first record live in a fantastic way. I think it was Store Bought Bones, one of my least favorites off that last record, that just had so much new life and psychedelic flavor.I think this new album is special for a lot of reasons. The kind of rock record that doesn't come along often. Rich Kid Blues is my favorite track of the moment. Great back and forth vocally between Jack and Brendan, interesting song structure, and organ parts reminiscent of ELP's Tarkus (I love that album!)Watching this show as a musician, I was reminded of the story of when someone or other (Clapton maybe, Townshend?) went to see Hendrix and wanted to simply hang it up. It was that humbling. This show almost made me feel like that. If I didn't have such a large ego filled with delusions of grandeur, that's exactly what I would do.Inspiring stuff indeed.

Comments (9)

  1. jenny says Nice write-up Neil. I've been meaning to check them out. I've always really liked Brendan Benson (do you have Lapalco? i love that record), nice to hear that he's more than just window-dressing. Someone told me that the Sadies are doing a few shows with these guys...have to look for those dates, I guess.
    Permalink posted 06/01/2008
  2. 1234chainsaw says Like Jenny, I really like Benson's solo stuff. And I like the earlier White Stripes stuff OK. The Raconteurs albums have left me kind of lukewarm (the first so more than the second, but the second hasn't hit me yet either). But now, having read your review, I'd really like to see them live. Sounds like it was extremely impressive.
    Permalink posted 06/01/2008
  3. NeilNathan says yeah, lapalco is quite perty i heard some of his new demos on my space and it sounds like the raconteurs are definitely having an effect on his writing and melodies the black lips were the opener at this show, fun high energy chainsaw, the live stuff is guaranteed to rock ya or i'll reimburse you! anything that sounds slightly overproduced or not quite in the pocket on the record, was organic and smooth live and usually more guitar heavy, which i dug
    Permalink posted 06/02/2008
  4. allenblakecassady says at roo they're playing at the same time as les claypool and I wasn't sure which I was going to... you just made my decision for me rock on neil.
    Permalink posted 06/02/2008
  5. NeilNathan says you will dig the vocals immensely enjoy the festival bro and don't take the brown acid
    Permalink posted 06/02/2008
  6. david hyman says i just saw them and bimbos and i concur. i walked out a happy better man.
    Permalink posted 06/03/2008
  7. NeilNathan says that feeling abounded at my show too david when you look around an nyc show and see jaded hipsters bopping their heads, smiling, punching their fists in the air and bouncing about, that is special it don't happen often
    Permalink posted 06/03/2008
  8. ZZTodd says i definitely plan on seeing them at ACL in September. this write up just set it in stone lol. i don't have the first album, but i bought the second one when it came out and i agree that it's fantastic. "Rich Kid Blues" is a great track on it for sure
    Permalink posted 06/03/2008
  9. Justin says Neil...I was at the show on 5/31. A great review...right on the mark. One just gets the feeling that those guys on stage are the real deal and that is refreshing. I kept turning to my friends yelling "rock n' roll!"....i felt no urge to say anything else throughout the evening. Normally, I do not caught up in how long a band plays on stage...but that being said, I felt The Raconteurs could have/should have played a longer show....there was no curfew that they were up against and they were playing the next night at the same venue so no traveling. I know this is their standard length show but come on...for $50, they can give us a 2 hour + show! I must say though that I do love their first album 'Broken Toy Soldiers'...you might want to revisit it.
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved