This explains so much...

Posted about 3 years ago

From the Guardian...

Headbanging does create risk of brain damage, says study

Forget cigarettes, fried food and holding your breath too long - there's another indulgence that some doctors wish to quash. Rockers should cease their headbanging, Australian scientists have advised, or wear a less-than-rocking neck brace.

"We identified a definite risk of mild traumatic brain injury from headbanging," Dr Andrew McIntosh, of the University of New South Wales (UNSW), told the Australian newspaper. "We would suggest a proper public health warning, as for smoking." The results of his research were published in the Christmas edition of the British Medical Journal.

Researchers at UNSW's school of risk and safety sciences found that risk of neck and head injury was directly related to song tempo. The average heavy metal song, with a tempo of 146 bpm, is likely to cause mild injury if the head's range of motion is greater than 75 degrees. Songs like Motley Crue's Kickstart My Heart - at 180 bpm - are among the most dangerous, leading to anything from mild headaches to mosh-induced strokes.

McIntosh and co-author Declan Patton advised that "Adult-oriented rock" is much more safe, as it involves a slower rate of head-bopping. We are not quite sure what "adult-oriented rock" means, but we suspect the music is less cool than AC/DC.

The study's authors also observed the headbanging of cartoon characters Beavis and Butthead. Listening to the Ramones' I Wanna Be Sedated, Beavis kept his "angular head velocity" within safe limits, they wrote. Butthead did not. "It is well understood, however, that cartoon characters are able to tolerate greater than normal impacts without injury," the study drily noted.

Injury can also be avoided by the use of a neck brace. Or, McIntosh advised, "learn to ballroom dance. That's the takeaway message".

So I'll be bringing the neckbraces to Coachella this year....

Comments (18)

  1. Dale says

    You promise to bring the neckbrace? heehee

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  2. Pop Savant says

    I saw AC/DC last week...and my brain does feel a little injured...I've been drinking Christmas beers as therapy and it appears to be working well

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  3. Misstee says

    thats right...someone else can supply the beer!

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  4. funoka says

    The older I get -- the more my neck hurts after a show -- just went to see Oasis and I was in mid-90s head bobbing form -- day 2 is always the worst.

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  5. lakposhti says

    My head hurts so bad anyway, I'm just holding my lighter up.

    BTW....bpm = bangs per minute?

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  6. Misstee says

    Bops per minute?

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  7. jaggerandrea says

    I actually know a guy who is a bass player (was in a band, now gives ocassional lessons) who actually messed up several of his upper vertebrae from headbanging over time.....he is in his mid forties but physically now, cuz of the damage, is in almost constant pain, and actually had to quit his "day" job (which was not labor intensive at all)--point is, I never thought so much about how much damage it can really do---and I have "head banged" quite a bit at certain concerts!!

    Be careful, that's all!

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  8. Misstee says

    I don't doubt the findings its just the context....an analysis of beavis and butthead?

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  9. jaggerandrea says

    LOL, well, yeah, I forgot to mention something about that, haha!

    --Beavis kept his angular head velocity within limits.......um, ok

    Heh, hmm-hmm-hmm-heh, hmm, hemmm----hard to write his laugh!

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  10. Mike the Knife says

    From "Bring the Noise" to "Bring the Neckbrace." Whoda thunk it?

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  11. Misstee says

    I'm waiting for another story where they say 'PSYCH!"

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  12. mollifire says

    if this is true, i would have been a frikkin genius instead of just insanely intelligent.  i'm inclined to say that i'm living proof that headbanging is perfectly safe unless you actually bang off the floor or yr guitar or something else hard.

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  13. Misstee says

    i think it all depends on who you are, your physical makeup and just how hard you 'bang'... I dislodge brain matter every time i try and wind up being dizzy for hours.

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  14. dachmo says

    I demonstrated a speed metel headbang, double horns and all, for my nephew last month and I still can't remember anything that happened between Halloween and Thanksgiving of this year. So yeah, article makes perfect sense.

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  15. Misstee says

    then clearly you had your head angled at 76 degrees...

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  16. Jonh Ingham says

    Trust the Australains to investigate this. Some uiversity aademics also had an investigation into how long a piece of string is. It's seven inches. I am not making this up.

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  17. Misstee says

    clearly they don't have enough to 'study' down under...

    Permalink posted 12/22/2008
  18. lakposhti says

    Dachmo - That's the funniest thing I've read all day.

    Permalink posted 12/24/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved