Out of the Mud and Back

Posted almost 4 years ago
I was just a little shaver finding my voice as a writer and pop music critic when I wrote a very favorable concert review of Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers. It was, I hoped, an accurate account of a club date that the folk-rock ‘n’ rollers played in Berkeley, CA., relatively early in the group’s career. And, despite my best efforts to contain my enthusiasm, it veered perilously close to one of those gushing I-have-seen-the-future-of-rock manifestos. The piece apparently struck a chord with at least one person, as I was to find out later.A year or so passed. I was attending another Heartbreakers show in the Bay Area - this one at a much larger venue. The band’s popularity was ever rising, and the hall was packed. The musicians delivered an inspiring set that left the crowd deliriously happy. As the audience headed home, a record-label meet-and-greet was underway. So I ambled backstage, where I engaged in the usual badinage with some colleagues.All of the Heartbreakers were working the room. Out of the corner of my eye, I noticed burgeoning singer-songwriter Petty deep in conversation with the legendary concert promoter Bill Graham who had presented the gig. Petty suddenly ended his chat with Graham, walked up to me, shook my hand, and sincerely asked me how I was doing. I told him, and inquired about the tour, which led to a short discussion of what artists and recordings we were each enjoying. At the smaller Berkeley show, I had spent a little time talking with Petty, guitarist Mike Campbell, and drummer Stan Lynch after their set. But that didn’t lessen my surprise that Petty recognized me a year later and decided to come over and jaw.Then, to my shock, he thanked me for my review from those many months ago, adding that he and the band thought it was one of the most flattering and encouraging things that had been written about them to date. “Now, we gotta live up to it,” he joked. I managed to mumble a “no problem,” thanked him for thanking me, and wished him well on the rest of his tour. We parted company, with him fielding a phalanx of admirers and me returning to my buddies who were by the buffet table and pumping beer out of an adjacent keg and into plastic cups. I recount this anecdote not to kiss my own ass (which, as it happens, would be an anatomical impossibility for me), but to point out what a gracious, unpretentious man Petty seemed to be as he was beginning his phenomenal run as one of the most successful and beloved rock musicians in America. I get the feeling that he’s still that same thoughtful, amiable guy. In fact, he seems to have cared enough about the comrades he came up with – the members of his pre-Heartbreakers band Mudcrutch – to reunite with them this past year, record some new tracks, and do a tour.It may not be a Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers album, per se, although two Heartbreakers - Campbell and keyboardist Benmont Tench – were and are members of Mudcrutch, the ensemble that migrated from Florida to Los Angeles to crack the music biz in the mid-1970s before splintering. But their reunion with the rest of the line-up, guitarist Tom Leadon and drummer Randall Marsh, has resulted in Mudcrutch, a terrific collection of tunes that revisits a Petty influence that has never been explored so extensively in his recording career: The early ‘70s country-rock excursions of The Byrds and Flying Burrito Brothers. As if to underline the point, Mudcrutch deftly covers The Byrds’ “Lover of the Bayou” and Dave Dudley’s 1963 country hit “Six Days on the Road,” the latter being a trucker anthem that was also a mainstay of the Burritos repertoire. (I’ll be damned if Mudcrutch's loping “Queen of the Go-Go Girls” couldn’t actually be a lost Gram Parsons honky-tonker from his days leading the Burrito Brothers.)“Shady Grove” establishes the album’s tone with a ringing variation on a traditional country-folk number - and the feat is repeated with the jaunty instrumental “June Apple.” The picking’s good (Leadon and Campbell on guitars); the skittering, shuffling rhythm is infectious (Marsh on sticks, and Petty back on bass, as he was when Mudcrutch started). Beyond that foundation, the project is primarily a rootsy, rustic ramble through rural and small-town America - taking the highways, following the byways, stopping off at the roadhouses, and eulogizing the lovers and the losers.“Scare Easy” is probably closest to the nexus of Petty’s familiar style (as in the self-actualizing sentiments and sing-along lure of “Don’t Back Down”), with its connections to Dylan, the Rolling Stones and, of course, The Byrds. But there’s also some twin-guitar Southern rock thunder in "Bootleg Flyer”; backwoods balladry sweetened by pedal steel in "Orphan of the Storm" (evoking the refugees of Hurricane Katrina); blues-rock in “The Wrong Thing to Do”; and even a lengthy, jammy excursion, “Crystal River,” adorned by a dreamy vocal, lashing guitar licks, and Tench’s surging organ fills, suggesting San Francisco psychedelia in the Quicksilver Messenger Service/Grateful Dead vein.Mudcrutch ends with the down-home acoustics of “House of Stone” – a hard-luck fellow’s plea for comfort and absolution that’s straight outta Bakersfield. (Dwight Yoakam, we’ve got a song for you.)Is this it for Mudcrutch? Only Petty and his pals know for sure, but it was a journey to the past that was well worth taking. If nothing else, it proved you can go home again – at least, for one album and tour.Here are the videos for “Lover of the Bayou” and “Scare Easy.” Looks like they enjoyed doing this as much as I enjoyed hearing it.“Lover of the Bayou”:“Scare Easy”:

Comments (39)

  1. satisfiedmind2 says That's it! This is the final straw...i have read several good reviews of this, and this is the one to put me over the top...excellent work Mike...you should be on the payroll!
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  2. Mike the Knife says satisfiedmind2: "Mike...you should be on the payroll!" Spreading the joy is reward enough, Blair. (O.K., guys. Where's my check?)
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  3. satisfiedmind2 says No, people NOT being on the payroll are what make MOG reviews worth reading!! Cheers
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  4. DaveCromwell says Yeah payroll = pay-hole! (which rhymes with a-hole) ok - not *everyone* who gets paid for writing is *only* doing it for the money (but you gotta admit, my "rhyme" works) Uh - yeah. Anyway - good blog, Mike ;-)
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  5. Mike the Knife says satisfiedmind2: You are correct, sir! I'm far more inclined to trust their opinions, if I know there's no payoff. DaveCromwell: I'm proud to say that no one has ever been able to bribe me for a good review. Oh, I've been approached, but I'm far more interested in maintaining what passes for my integrity. Ultimately, it's just my informed opinion, and there's no accounting for bad taste...
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  6. Madeline Burke says OUTSTANDING! thanks for this great post....MMM-MMM-MMM!
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  7. contrabandwidth says Seriously. I might just think Petty IS as down to earth as he seems. Definitely one of those workhorses of Rock, often over shadowed by others, but able to hold his own. Sounds like a great listen that I'll have to get my grubby ears on.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  8. Mike the Knife says Madeline Burke: You are most welcome! contrabandwidth: Check it out, and, if inclined, let me know what you think. One of my favorite things about the album is how loosey-goosey and off-hand it feels. Re: Petty being down to earth. If you haven't heard/see him as Lucky, Luann's lovable ne'r-do-well husband on the animated cartoon series "King of the Hill," he's totally great - and unafraid to poke fun at himself.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  9. contrabandwidth says Yeah, I've heard some interviews - one with Conan comes to mind, where he talks about getting to be on an episode of The Simpsons, and how his kids pretty much never thought he was that famous until that moment. Petty saids something in response to them like "what do you think I've been doing for the past 30 years?" He just seemslike like a real nice guy.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  10. fistula spume says I forgot all about this coming out. At first glance I thought it said "Mudcrotch". I bet with some Yoga classes and removal of a few ribs and you can kiss your own butt Mike. :p I'm liking what I'm hearing. How cool that you got recognized and he remembered your review. What an awesome compliment.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  11. Mike the Knife says contrabandwidth: Yep. Talent aside, nice guy - and one that finished first. I think that says it. fistula spume: Ow! My back! (I'd be lying if I didn't say that Petty's kindness did wonders for my confidence and helped inspire me to keep pursuing a career in journalism.)
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  12. fistula spume says It definitely would be a boost. I get that feeling when really cool artists tell me they like my artwork. I wish I had a career in journalism. :(
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  13. Mike the Knife says fist: Be careful what you wish for...
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  14. fistula spume says Has to beat being an insurance zombie. Although the benefits are good.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  15. Bartleby says Artists and their musicians will know what posterity tastes whereas critics are hardly ever remembered. However I think you've proven with this remarkable depiction of Mudcrutch's music than it is not necessarily true; that critics are can be remembered by the musicians whose work they review. I must confess I entertain a natural distrust for reviewers as they aim more at literary creativity than "musical objectivity" but I think this might just be the perfect balance between critical style and lyrical precision. Thank you Mike, your review has whetted my appetite for more Mudcrutch (even though I've never been a huge fan of Petty).
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  16. Rawkkiddoh says See, this is what I have been missing being neck deep in fourth grade life. It is so refreshing to come on tonight and read this, and yes Mike you should at least try and kiss your own ass. A compliment like that coming from Tom would make me double over and at least try and hit the spot
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  17. indiepixie says i am so envious. petty approval. awesome :)
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  18. Mike the Knife says fistula spume: Benefits? What are these things called benefits? Bartleby: I've never depended on the approval of others, even as I dish it out (or withhold it). But it's certainly nice to have my attempts at insight appreciated. So thanks to you, Bart. Very kind. Rawkkiddoh: Wow, Kevin. One day back, and you're already vying for the honor of being my favorite Trusted. All joshing aside, there was nothing petty about my experience with Petty. (I'm not sure, because there were no mirrors around, but I actually may have blushed when he said what he said.) indiepixie: C'mon, Faith. Envious? You? Confidante of Michael Stipe, Lou Reed and Perry Farrell? Pish and tosh, as my maiden aunt would have said had she been a rich old lady in a mansion.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  19. fistula spume says It's what you get when you sign over your soul so you feel a false sense of satiation.
    Permalink posted 06/04/2008
  20. Cody B says Nice one,Knife. Besides the talent, there's a good reason Mr. Petty's been around so long. He genuinely seems like a decent person. A musician instead of a star. Not too many of those at the arena level.
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  21. ted baylis says I'm glad you found Petty so affable and down to earth. Listening to his XM "Buried Treasure Show" one walks away with a similar assessment. Love his Mudcrutch stuff
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  22. vannatta says ...wow... great post (as usual) Sir Knife... really digging this too... thanks!
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  23. kat3260 says Tom Petty was one of my earliest music discoveries...I listened to Damn The Torpedoes incessantly. He's one of those musicians that is quality but sadly he gets easily brushed aside for me. Thanks for reminding me that he totally rocks...this Mudcrutch album was right on time.
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  24. HelenMarie says "payroll = pay-hole! (which rhymes with a-hole)" hahahaha! Thanks Mike! Will a little gratitude do...?
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  25. Augusts1 says Never been much of a Petty fan although I've enjoyed a song here & there over the years. His songwriting/musicianship skill is admirable too. I'm just not that wild about his style of music, to me it's not interesting. This album doesn't seem to stray too far from his usual style either(although the 'Shady Grove' song is a refreshing change). Thanks for the great review & that's so cool you got kudos from Tom.
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  26. Mike the Knife says Cody B: True beyond a doubt. It's so easy for fame, wealth and adulation to create assholes. Seems like Petty didn't allow that to happen in his case. ted baylis: Yep. And I'm still a fan, even if he's on a (for now) rival satellite station. (They might take my Sirius gig away if I don't show some brand loyalty.) vannatta: Most welcome, mon! Sometimes even urbanites (me) need a little Americana rustica. kat3260: You bet he rocks, still and always. I'd say that great is great, whether it's at the top of the queue or sifted out of memory. SunshineDaydream: Gratitude is always in order when a gift is given... August: Righty-o! Different strokage shouldn't preclude respect. As ever, nice to hear from you.
    Permalink posted 06/05/2008
  27. FluxCapacitor says Great story, Mike. I think it serves as a reminder to reviewers to be as generous as possible with their comments because you never know who's reading. I must try it some day! Know nothing of Petty beyond Free Falling, but I'm digging this tune...
    Permalink posted 06/06/2008
  28. Mike the Knife says Flux: Very collegial of you! Truth be told, I try to just be honest. Only if something sucks will I bring out the daggers to skewer it. There's no excuse for bad art, whether due to pretension or incompetence.
    Permalink posted 06/06/2008
  29. poebegone says whoah, this post is superior, Mr. Knifey, a cut above the lot. heck, many cuts above. when i tried my hand in journalism fresh out of school, i got a constant deluge of gifts, from blah to bizarro, but it was always being remembered with good reason that was most rewarding. i suspect Petty is that down to earth, he really does seem like a nice guy. i am also loving the returning-home currents of the review. 12 out of 10 stars. (;
    Permalink posted 06/07/2008
  30. Mike the Knife says poe, you flatterer! Merci! It's always been home-and-away-and-home for me, and this nomadic soul would have it no other way! Remember where you're from. It might help you get where you're going...
    Permalink posted 06/07/2008
  31. wassonii says typically, I am late to the post;) Fantastic infos on this incarnation. Of course I have seen some stuffs on it, but hadn't heard from the album, so thank you. What a great experience and album review, brother. What a great turn on. Thank you!
    Permalink posted 06/08/2008
  32. Mike the Knife says wassonii: You're never too late to enjoy some fine music, wass. And it's always a pleasure to have you check in and comment!
    Permalink posted 06/08/2008
  33. NeilNathan says thanks mike for the tip gotta pick this up and thank you infinity for pointing me to kevin and blair, those sneaky bastards i had no idea they were back hooray for the old school moggers
    Permalink posted 06/10/2008
  34. Mike the Knife says NeilNathan: Happy to be of service. It's what we do here, me bucko! Old school rules!
    Permalink posted 06/10/2008
  35. Wade says

    this is great story. i remember when damn the torpedoes came out, though it wasn't his first, it was the first i heard.  i was in 7th grade or so. it was good then, and it is great now. for a while i quit following him cuz he just seemed too popular, i could always hear his songs on  the radio and with my punk rock friends in high school, well he was not really the right thing to have in your collection. i am amazed at the high quality stuff he continues to put out.

    Permalink posted 06/21/2008
  36. Mike the Knife says

    Wade: I too continue to be amazed at Petty's consistency. BTW, I always had enough room in my heart for punk, power-pop, folk-rock, etc. No reason to ignore great music just 'cause it doesn't fit certain stylistic parameters,

    Permalink posted 06/22/2008
  37. p-wagz says

    This is great stuff.  The guitars on some of "Shady Grove" sounds eerily similar to a Shawn Mullins song, "Cold Black Heart", so check that out and let me know what you think, if you don't already know of Mr. Mullins.

    I've never been a huge fan of Petty, but that sound just pulls me in now.

    Permalink posted 09/07/2008
  38. Mike the Knife says

    p-wagz: I'm familiar with Mullins. Good stuff. May I recommend revisiting some of Petty's earlier material?

    Permalink posted 09/08/2008
  39. p-wagz says

    I will do that most definitely, thanks for the suggestion.

    Permalink posted 09/08/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved