THE MUSIC BLOGGING HIVE MIND

Slightly Tarnished, But Golden

Posted about 1 year ago
A century or so ago, George Sterling, poet laureate of San Francisco, referred to the town as his "cool gray city of love." Legendary Bay Area newspaper columnist Herb Caen used the term on many occasions, but it came to mind after listening to The Golden Age, the latest - and surprisingly lovely - album from singer-songwriter Mark Eitzel's dark-hued confessional-folk-rock band American Music Club.As longtime San Francisco residents, Eitzel and AMC guitarist Vudi (the only members that remain in the group from its most prolific period) know and understand the city, its foggy waterfront, its shadowy alleys, and its Bohemian citizenry. Thus, despite relocating to Los Angeles prior to recording this album (the second since Eitzel revived the band name after a decade of solo projects), San Francisco is still very much in AMC's consciousness. Two of the 13 tracks on The Golden Age name-check the unique destination that Caen also called Baghdad-by-the-Bay: “All the Lost Souls Welcome You to San Francisco” - a gentle, loping ode to the town and its loveable misfits - and the album’s delicate coda “The Grand Duchess of San Francisco.” We know where Eitzel and Vudi have left their hearts, even if they’re working with an L.A. rhythm section (bassist Sean Hoffman and drummer Steve Didelot) and living in the Basin; they remain connected to the beauty, mystery and wasted-hipster vibe of their old haunts.The Golden Age? Eitzel may be playing the sarcasm card here. He’s never struck me as much of an optimist. But the tenor of songs such as the opening track “All My Love” - with Eitzel’s muzzy/fuzzy/sweet vocal and sonorous acoustic guitar picking and an open-hearted lyric filled with promises and promise – implies mellowing and affirmation. Wistful in tone, “The Sleeping Beauty” is about loss; it's also about acceptance. Even “The Decibels and the Little Pills” – a rambling country-flavored number that finds the singer staring into the abyss - is ultimately a statement of empowerment suggesting that we choose life over the cold alternative.2004's Love Songs for Patriots - essentially, AMC’s comeback album – was very much concerned with the war in Iraq, the toll it was taking, and the price that’s still being paid at home and abroad. The usually depressed and dolorous Eitzel was clearly pissed off about the state of the world, and venting. The Golden Age is more introspective and lighter than the previous album. That doesn’t mean Eitzel is going to ignore the elephant in the War Room. “The Windows on the World” – a hindsight-wise reflection on New York City and complacency, pre-9/11 - and “The Dance” - a rumination on violence and culpability that builds in intensity with a stinging Vudi solo - bring the personal and political together with incendiary results.“The Stars” is too much draggy lamentation for my tastes, but that one misstep is offset by the honor and determination expressed in “One Step Ahead” and the honest sentiment of “Who You Are.”Neil Young comes to mind, in the most flattering way, when Vudi rips off an incendiary lick or Eitzel confects a rustic waltz such as “I Know That's Not Really You” – like the echo from an liquored-up barn dance over the ridge. Still, no one would mistake Eitzel’s gruff voice and simmering turmoil for anyone else’s. And The Golden Age is the man at his revelatory best, working through his troubles and making peace with demons within and without – while offering a bit of hope and tunefulness in the process.

Comments (20)

  1. Zeroskilz says Thanks for sharing. I'd heard of this band but hadn't heard anything by them yet. Nice review.
    Permalink posted 03/19/2008
  2. 1234chainsaw says It's not exactly obvious, but I think this is primarily a positive review. I'm glad finally to see it, and it has piqued my interest. I take it that you mean AMC is more mellow in sentiment, not necessarily in instrumentation? ("All My Love" in any case doesn't indicate anything else.) I'll be out of town for a bit, but I think a visit to Amoeba is in order while I'm in SF for the MOG meet and to hang out with my dad during his conference visit!
    Permalink posted 03/19/2008
  3. Mike the Knife says Zeroskilz: Sharing is caring, Z. You are welcome. 1234chainsaw: Primarily positive? Yes. And, as I said, the album is surprisingly lovely. I suppose that would be in comparison to the more rampantly downbeat stuff in the Eitzel canon. There's a certain mellowness of sentiment and sound, although Vudi knows how to slash out a guitar line when needed. Again, it's all relative to earlier AMC stuff. (Amoeba or bust, P.)
    Permalink posted 03/19/2008
  4. 1234chainsaw says Surely, Amoeba and (wallet-)bust!?
    Permalink posted 03/19/2008
  5. Augusts1 says Nice review. That's a beautiful song too. Didn't realize Eitzel & crew were a SF band.
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  6. dermahrk says 100 years later, it's still the "cool gray city of love". Only the r has been lost. Nice track. Much better than Neil Young, IMHO.
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  7. jenny says I really like this album, Mike. Nice job.
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  8. fistula spume says Great review. The track has a nice flow to it. This kind of music can go so wrong for me in a matter of notes but this one hooked me. Nevah hoid before. Thx!!
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  9. w1llits says nice write-up. i like that you included the background and roots in san francisco- a city who's artists are slowly being smothered into the gutters of non-existance by the rich...sorry, that's another issue altogether. i hadn't heard much american music club before and i really liked it. good stormy weather tunes; both literally and otherwise.
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  10. vannatta says ...really good tune... thanks!
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  11. Mike the Knife says 1234chainsaw: All too true... August: Thanks, man. I'd suggest a certain measure of civic pride might have come through in the review, but that's to be expected. dermahrk: You can number me among the cool gray straight men who are still in love with that city - and we certainly outnumber our cool gay neighbors. BTW, I don't know what happened between you and Neil Young. You used to seem so happy together... jenny: You're on the mark about Mark, and you're too kind about my review. But I appreciate the kind words. fistula spume: Yep. That's a purty number. And I'm happy to pass it along. w1llits: It's a little disheartening how artists are often disregarded, despite providing beauty/entertainment/insight for the wealthy and the masses. Nonetheless, I'm more than delighted to shine a light on S.F. and its talented denizens. vannatta: De nada!
    Permalink posted 03/20/2008
  12. annieander says Very nice song and post Mike - San Francisco has always been burned into my soul...not many cities have that distinction.
    Permalink posted 03/24/2008
  13. Mike the Knife says annieander: Ouch! That's gotta hurt. But seriously, it's the same for me with S.F., NoLa, NYC, and Paris. They envelop me, they nurture me, and they're always with me.
    Permalink posted 03/24/2008
  14. annieander says Mike - You are a very nice person...I had to say it...eventhough it didn't need to be said.
    Permalink posted 03/24/2008
  15. Michael Goldberg says Excellent review. AMC remain one of the great San Francisco bands, one of the great bands, period. They were always way better than their record sales, and I still listen to the amazing albums they released in the late '80s and early '90s. It's too bad that the original lineup isn't still together, but Mark and Vudi have done great work on this one with the new rhythm section.
    Permalink posted 03/24/2008
  16. Mike the Knife says annieander: Oh, I'll bet you say that to all the wasted hipsters. ;-) Michael Goldberg: Thanks a heap, M.G. That's high praise indeed (for the review and, certainly, for AMC), coming from you. This is, for the record, one of those albums that gets better and better with each listen...
    Permalink posted 03/24/2008
  17. Kronski says "Eitzel’s muzzy/fuzzy/sweet vocal and sonorous acoustic guitar picking and an open-hearted lyric filled with promises and promise – implies mellowing and affirmation." I really like the way you worded the description of the posted song. The best part of this album, the thing that I come away with is all contained in the line above. Oh and I think that "Who You Are" should be played in every therapist's office in the world. Nice review!
    Permalink posted 03/25/2008
  18. Mike the Knife says I appreciate the favorable response, Kronski. I'll inform my therapist that you liked my review. ;-)
    Permalink posted 03/27/2008
  19. tybees says I keep returning to this post to play that song again.
    Permalink posted 04/14/2008
  20. Mike the Knife says Enjoy, ty! (And the rest of the album is equally worth your attention.)
    Permalink posted 04/14/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved