WHERE MUSIC LISTENS TO YOU

Me2 3D

Posted about 1 year ago
Tears started to well up in my eyes as I gazed upon the big screen. Not a flood of ‘em, mind you. But there was a definite rise in the moisture level. And this was no tragic narrative playing out before me. It was a concert documentary – albeit one of a high order.Have I succumbed to severe wussification? Has time dulled the Knife? I don’t think so. I think it was a fairly normal reaction, considering that it was an emotional peak in the three-dimensional IMAX film “U2 3D,” which is opening this week in various venues across the U.S. And who has had a more successful, long-lived career by tapping into the power and passion of rock and roll than U2 – the magnificent (and somewhat self-important) Irish band that rose to fame during the new-wave era of the early ‘80s, and never came down?There I was, sitting in the middle of an IMAX theater in downtown San Francisco at 11:45 AM with a handful of critics and their guests, all wearing oversized 3D glasses, yet bouncing from the crowd to the stage where I was thrust right into the middle of a balls-out live performance by Bono, singing his guts out, while guitarist The Edge, bass-player Adam Clayton and drummer Larry Mullen Jr. brought considerably more than rattle and hum.After the cameras swerve and pan through a crammed-full Latin American stadium (the main footage appeared to be from concerts in Buenos Aires, Brazil, Mexico and other stops on the 2006 leg of the Vertigo Tour), the band opens with “Vertigo” from the Grammy-winning How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb, their most recent studio album. It rips, and the crowd is immediately driven into a frenzy. A zillion mobile phones and digital cameras are raised to capture the moment – and all the arms and devices sprout like a strange forest of illuminated flowers in 3D.The U2 guys have been at it for more than 25 years, but they’re still lean and focused, and their composing and performing skills are relatively undimmed. As ever, Bono was earnest and energetic. There’s a certain pretension to a couple of tunes (“Miss Sarajevo” comes to mind), which is either enhanced or hammered to distraction by images that flash across a very impressive, very elaborate, multi-tiered video display. But Bono knows how to work an audience and provide a sense of verity and commitment.They run through almost an hour and a half of beloved tracks – “With or Without You,” “Beautiful Day,” “Sunday Bloody Sunday,” “New Year’s Day,” and so on - with increasing resonance. A sense of magic happening is inescapable as these grandiose anthems come rolling out.The song that pushed me over the top? “In the Name of Love,” done before a digital frieze of Martin Luther King. They follow that with a totally thrilling version of “Where the Streets Have No Name” (my all-time of all-time U2 songs), and I’m walloped. Lump in my throat. Dampened corneas. I went all Winston Smith. I loved Big Brothers.Was it the sense-immersion of IMAX and 3D? (By the way, the women of Buenos Aires – at least those that attended the U2 show - are a wonder to behold, and in 3D, whoa!) The technology, both sound and vision, and the expert direction (by Catherine Owens and Mark Pellington) and cinematography certainly contributed to the impact, leading me to wonder why we can’t have this sort of document of all our favorite bands. All that said, it was with (not without) U2 and their memorable songbook. And that’s the rub.Guess who was responsible for the single most exciting rock performance that I’ve seen on television in at least 20 years? On the November 20, 2004 episode of NBC’s “Saturday Night Live” (hosted by Luke Wilson), musical guest U2 - promoting How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb - returned for a rare (for SNL) third song played into and over the end credits: “I Will Follow,” taken from their 1980 album debut Boy. I have never seen such spontaneous combustion erupt on my TV. And the heat was palpable. Bono and crew shook the Rockefeller Center studio, the cast and the audience to their souls. Even watching a Quicktime file of the number in a tiny window on my desktop, it’s goosebump time.Joke about Bono the Humanitarian and the band’s wealth and fame, if you like. I think of them as a force for good and a stunningly accomplished ensemble that’s still gettin’ it done. And if you want to see what the fuss is all about, go to “U2 3D.”In the meantime, here’s “Where the Streets Have No Name,” from the 2002 Super Bowl halftime show - a few short months after the 9/11 attacks. Call me corny. It continues to move me, five years later.

Comments (18)

  1. Augusts1 says Wow, that is quite moving Mike. I think U2 is such a vital band emotionally & musically. They continue to make such stirring music even now. Great review. I've gotta see that!
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  2. darmuzz says Likewise, hope to see it this weekend!
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  3. Spike says For that monumental performance, they deserve the mass frenzy. I remember feeling the same way about their last concert in San Jose, as big surprise to me because my only previous exposure to them was not liking their _Joshua Tree_ album.
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  4. Jonh Ingham says I'm pretty neutral on U2 - they've made some corkers and they've made some dross, but it's good to see that they still care about it. Similar to the SNL experience, they were on Jonathan Ross - the UK's version of Letterman - and did a serious and rocktastic version of 'I Will Follow'. A few days later they played live for Top Of The Pops out in the BBC parking lot to a bunch of fans. It was raining but they still did 'Vertigo' like it was their big break. When the end credits came the picture cut back to the parking lot and the group were still playing for the kids. Respect.
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  5. Mike the Knife says August: Appreciated! darmuzz: As I tried to say, it's quite a satisfying experience. I might even go a second time... Spike: Bono & company: Winning friends and influencing people for two and a half decades... Jonh: Indeed. I want to diss them, but I see gigs and clips that reinforce their greatness. Of course, they can pick and choose the best material from 25 years of recording - including recent stuff that I dig - for a concert, and bring down the sky. (So, they were good on Wossy's show? Not too surprised. They also kept playing in TV studio after that "Saturday Night Live" ep ended. Two or three or four more songs. See if you can find the video. As the credits run, it's obvious that Amy Poehler, Maya Rudolph, Rachel Dratch and Seth Myers of the SNL ensemble are in full weep-for-joy mode. See? It's not just me.)
    Permalink posted 01/23/2008
  6. FluxCapacitor says Fantastic write-up. Love the personal touch, so often missing from music reviews. And that clip is fucking phenomenal. I thought we go crazy in Dublin at their concerts, but you can feel the emotion pouring out of the audience. Wild abandon doesn't even cover it. **preens with national pride I didn't know I still had**
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  7. dermahrk says Oh God...a three-story high Bono? Be still my stomach...
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  8. QueenofHell says Sounds like it's worth a watch, even though I'm not a U2 fan. Where The Streets Have No Name is probably my favourite U2 song, too. But I prefer the Pet Shop Boys' version mixed with I Can't Take My Eyes Off You. So wonderfully camp and dancey. I find it funny because Neill Tennant and Chris Lowe didn't like rock music (they probably still don't) and they turned U2s rock anthem into a camped up disco track. Wonderful.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  9. kristiana says I'm right there with ya Mike, blubber away! Stop apologizing for liking U2, they were and are all that. It's one of my favorite songs too, for sure. Yeah, see - if I was standing right there in that crowd with ya Mikey, and looked around me...who do you think I would wanna be friends with? The guy getting teary-eyed to a fucking awesome anthem from our youth (some more than others ;), or the guy standing there cross-armed saying "yeah, it's all right, I suppose."? :) Funny, Dale just wrote a post about U2 recently too.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  10. kristiana says Wow. Thanks for the video. I waited and came back to it. Pa-POW. And this is why I love them. They continue to get up there and talk about love, and in that way that leaves you feeling "how could you talk about anything else?". Especially at the time of this video, so perfect. Damn perfect. And opening up his jacket there at the end was pretty cheesy, granted. But I loved it. All of a sudden I was seeing this kid in front of me again. Except, um, I guess the flag being white and all. Yes, you know the clip all too well. But you know you want to watch it anyway.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  11. Mike the Knife says FluxCapacitor: Puff up, man. They deserve the love. dermahrk: Try some Pepto-Bismol, pal. QueenofHell: Aw, Hell. Let not my affection for the U2 original lead you to think that I am any less than jazzed to the max whenever I hear the Neill & Chris take. It's tied with "What Have I Done to Deserve This?" as my personal Pet Shop Boys pinnacle. kristiana: Beautiful. We can share a packet of Kleenex. And no surprise about Dale's ever-superb taste. BTW , thank YOU for the blast from the past. They sure know spectacle, don't they? Posted
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  12. QueenofHell says I didn't think that you would not be jazzed by the PSB's version. Actually, Terry Staunton told me that when he enquired about the U2 response to the PSB version for the NME, Bono's good humoured response was 'What Have I Done To Deserve This'.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  13. Mike the Knife says Perfect, Helen.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  14. Lady Miss Ian says Hi Mike - sounds like quite the experience. Surround sound AND surround picture? Amazing. No shame for the emotion. That's what music is suppose to be about anyway, right? I've been in the lukewarm bucket about U2 for after Unforgettable Fire, but I give them mucho props for 1) treating their fans right and, 2) always putting on a great show. They know how to do it. I hadn't even heard of this 3D film coming out. Any others in the pipeline? Though I'm not a giant fan of theirs, The Flaming Lips comes to mind as a good 3D concert subject.
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  15. Mike the Knife says Lady Miss Ian: Not sure about other 3D hoedowns, but the Flaming Lips would be ideal!
    Permalink posted 01/24/2008
  16. jenny says I'd like to see this. I used to love U2, haven't thought about them seriously in a while, but War and October are in my all-time best pile....if I could just find it, I know I left it somewhere.
    Permalink posted 01/25/2008
  17. Augusts1 says Mike, last night I ran across an _old_ letter from a friend dated 1983(the friend responsible for turning me onto alternative music). He was telling me he'd bought a ticket to see this new band who was coming to Portland, OR by the name of U2 & wondered if I'd heard of them(I don't recall if I had or not by then)! When I read this last night I immediately thought of your post, haha.
    Permalink posted 01/25/2008
  18. Mike the Knife says jenny: Hmmm. Was it the vinyl pile, or the CD pile - or a virtual pile? August: That's rich. Well, my motto has always been "Get there first. Then, get the hell out." But U2 stuck around, and, apparently, so did I...
    Permalink posted 01/29/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved