YOU CAN'T NOT GET NO SATISFACTION

Making Up With An Ex

Posted over 2 years ago
Tomorrow I have to submit an assignment and write a midterm and oh I'm so behind. This is of course why I feel the need to Mog.I've been thinking a lot about Our Lady Peace lately and in particular, whether it's okay to swallow your pride and admit to liking a band you tossed aside as rubbish.They were one of my first favourite bands back in '97. Clumsy had just come out and while at this time I was not a "music person" at all, I got to listen to it from classmates who would play it during art class.At first, I didn't understand it. To quote one of my friends "If you listened to this stuff all the time you'd go crazy". Yes, we were bubblegum pop teenybopper types and rock just didn't make a lot of sense to us. However, after a while I fell in love with the combination of great musicianship and Raine's warbling vocals. This may have been the first time I actually really liked rock music.That Christmas, I got both Clumsy and Naveed making them some of the first cds that I ever owned. Clumsy became an instant classic- I played it constantly. Naveed took some time to grow on me since it was, well, different. It didn't have the familiar songs and it was more about the crazy guitar riffs. Looking back, it's now my favourite OLP album by far and I would say the best Canadian album of the 90s. Seriously, go listen to it.Fast-forward to 1999. OLP were releasing a new album (Happiness...) and being a new superfan, I picked it up the day it was released and how I was disappointed. Gone were the guitar riffs in favour of incredibly slow, mellow music. I tried to console myself by thinking at least I can fall asleep to this.Since then, I've completely written off the band. They went from absolutely amazing songs like Starseed to mediocre crap like Innocent, a song that makes me want to rip my ears off.However, a few months ago I heard their song "Angels/Losing/Sleep" on the radio and oh I found myself secretly liking it after trashing the band. I considered it a fluke (every band tends to have at least one likeable song) and always felt shameful listening to it. Just yesterday, I heard another new OLP song on the radio (which one I don't know) and I was completely struck by how not-bad it was. It might even be considered good.Now I feel like I've been unfair and should give them a chance again as much as it pains me. When I take a stand on bands I like to stick to it but they just keep making me go back.Has anyone else experience this sort of thing before, where you publicly proclaim to dislike a band and then they end up surprising you? Is it okay to go back on what you said and like a band or does it just make you a hypocrite?Whatever the case, I think I should listen to Healthy In Paranoid Times to see if they have in fact stopped sucking.

Comments (10)

  1. lemontwist says Hmmmm... I haven't listened to anything they made after Happiness. I really loved Naveed, and loved Clumsy (but not as much as Naveed). I owned Happiness but lost it and haven't listened in a while, but I know I don't like it as much as Clumsy... But the other stuff I've heard on the radio was just awful. Let me know if Healthy is any good, because I'm skeptical. Just like you. :)
    Permalink posted 11/14/2006
  2. Heggs says I'm glad someone else agrees that they were great and then started to suck. My personal theory is that it's all Chantal Kreviazuk's fault. Also, if anyone can send me some songs off of HIPT that'd be awesome since there's no way I'm buying this thing without listening to it first.
    Permalink posted 11/14/2006
  3. rweyh04 says Never let a run of bad ablums/songs make you completely write off a band. You can write it off 99% but save that 1% in case they come back strong. Plus you could be missing out on good tunes if you want to stubbornly stick to a position based on their bad works and not their entire work.
    Permalink posted 11/14/2006
  4. Heggs says Good advice but it's not that easy to take. Loving and hating music is part of being passionate about it.
    Permalink posted 11/14/2006
  5. lemontwist says Heggs, I'll see what I can do about hooking you up with some HIPT. We can take the plunge together. If I can find some tracks I'll send you a mog mail...
    Permalink posted 11/15/2006
  6. dbboucher says I like most of their material, but certainly Naveed and Clumsy are probably the best. I have a different problem in Canada though. Here they are overplayed to death. I swear I bought their CDs but never felt like listening to them because I had heard way too much from them already...
    Permalink posted 11/15/2006
  7. Heggs says dbboucher, I'm Canadian too ya know! How else would they have been one of the first bands I got into? I find the trick to not tiring of radio singles is to just stop listening to it. So was HIPT any good and do you want to hook up lemontwist and myself with some tunes?
    Permalink posted 11/15/2006
  8. dbboucher says lemontwist already knows me on multiply. If you create an account there I can hand pick some tracks from their less popular albums if you want to re-try them.
    Permalink posted 11/15/2006
  9. Pseudo Cyborg says I wrote off Placebo The first time I heard "Pure Morning". I absolute despise that song. Luckily a friend of mine convinced me to give Black Market Music a go. I'm glad I finally did... 3 years after it came out. Meds sealed the deal. I'm of the opinion that it's currently one of the top 3 albums released this year.
    Permalink posted 11/15/2006
  10. xana2 says I've never really completely written off a band, just lost interest in buying their music...but, as far as OLP is concerned, the last couple of albums were at first listen not as great as the first 2, but I've learned that sometimes, music you hate the first time you listen to it can grow on you and become your favorite, if its truely great stuff. That happened to me on Naveed, I hated it so much I almost sold it, but I listened to it again, and it became one of my favorite records. The last 2 were the same, because they are so different it turns you off at first, but go back and listen again. I have never heard anyone any where close to the genius that is Raine Maida and I think every record OLP has made is worth buying.
    Permalink posted 03/26/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved