The Only Living College Boys In New York

Posted about 4 years ago
I’ve a special place in my black heart for popular artists working in much-derided genres who nonetheless do great work. Work on par, or (shock! horror!) better, than that from mediums or genres that most people automatically assume to be high art – like theatre, ballet, or dubstep. The world of pop is a much-derided genre. It’s seen as frivolous, fey and, indeed, gay. Of course, if anybody said so to my face, I wouldn’t hesitate to beat on their chest while crying, “You brute! You brute!” And I hope that would be an end to the matter. On their eponymous debut album, Vampire Weekend offer a better reply to the catcalls. Eleven shimmering pop songs infused with intelligence, good humour, and a little collegiate craziness. The Columbia University quartet have the potential to bring some class to the masses. If the masses let them, that is. Despite having songs seemingly custom built for your young niece to sing along with on the radio, there is a problem. The problem is class. Not that they lack it. They simply have the wrong type. That’s right, these poor, pitiful creatures are _upper_ class. (Topsy-turvey world, pop!) What’s more, VW don’t attempt to hide their shameful background by dressing as tramps - like The Strokes. Nope, they wear their Ivy League educations like a badge (or rather, a Ralph Lauren logo). VW will have their clothing preppy, their lyrics laced with literary (and architectural and nautical) references, and their music rinsed through that stuff most people only listen to as students – what’s it called again? Oh yeah, world music. Therefore resistance could be great. Who do these rich assholes think they are barging onto the music scene? Don’t they know music is one of the few social equalizers we have left? And what's this? They’re playing black people’s music while dressed as Republicans! Jesus, they probably _are_ Republicans! Well, if so, they’re the PJ O’Rourke of pop. Sly-humoured social and society critics with a nonconformist spirit and a half-hidden (non-Republican) pining for a better world. This modus operandi is highly apparent in the breezy piano-driven Walcott. Songwriter Ezra Koenig extols his titular buddy to get “out of Cape Cod tonight”. In support, Koenig humorously lists all the things he finds wrong with this rich man’s playground, “bottleneck is a shitshow…Hyannisport is a ghetto”. Instead he points Walcott to “the mystic seaport.” Without saying so overtly, Koenig’s narrator fears for his pal’s soul. On stirring orchestral closer The Kids Don’t Stand A Chance, Koenig employs some nursery rhyme imagery, as well as a falsetto, to suggest the fragile and ephemeral nature of childhood in an increasingly corporate-controlled world. “The pinstripe men of morning/are coming for to dance/(with) $40 million dollars/ the kids don’t stand a chance.” Thematically, as well as in elegiac sweep, this is a redux of Sting’s actually quite good 80s power ballad Russians for us more easily embarrassed folk of the 21st Century. Campus offers opposition to the soulless culture of the “hook-up” that’s swept through US colleges in recent years. Keonig’s lovelorn narrator has trouble moving on to the next conquest like you’re supposed to. He asks himself, “How am I supposed to pretend/I never want to see you again?” Heart on sleeve Koenig evokes beautifully the college romance – and the romance of college—with his plaintive closing refrain: “In the afternoon you’re out on the stone and grass/And I’m sleeping on the balcony after class”. Not all Koenigs lyrics are as easy to understand, though. In the otherwise effortlessly accessible opener Mansard Roof, we’re left to ponder the meaning of “The Argentines collapse in defeat/The admiralty surveys the remnants of the fleet/The ground beneath their feet/Is a nautically-mapped sheet.”I fear Koenig indulges too much in that great mainstream artist David Milch (writer of Hill Street Blues, NYPD Blue, and Deadwood) calls fanciful association. That is, references too personal for your audience to understand. Milch finds them self-indulgent and strikes them out. Koenig must follow suit if he wants to hit the mainstream as hard as (still) the greatest indie pop writer of the moment, Alex Turner. Or perhaps Vampire Weekend have done enough already. Afterall, hasn't Kanye West already rocked the preppy look to great success? Let’s hope it's paved the way for the real deal. Jaunty, fun songs like Oxford Comma and Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa deserve to be heard by an audience wider than the kewl kidz on the web -- most of whom, as is their nature, have already moved on to the Next Small Thing. And couldn’t your young niece do with a bit of culture? No offence, gentle reader, but if she's anything like you, I think she probably could. . . ."Vampire Weekend" released 29 Jan 08.VW @ "MySpace":http://www.myspace.com/vampireweekend VW @ "Hype Machine":http://hypem.com/artist/vampire+weekendMy review of "Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa":http://mog.com/FluxCapacitor/blog_post/83765Over the jump - listen to "Campus".

Comments (42)

  1. FluxCapacitor says Campus [2:57] ~W7urJiKQ0oh.mp3~
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  2. TynansAnger says Wonder if my dad taught any of these kids. Will definitely check them out.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  3. myonlyappeal says I just recently bought the album. You're spot on about it.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  4. kristiana says Another kickass read, thanks Colin! I do remember enjoying them on your other post. Ok ok, I'll go look into it further, already.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  5. scotfree says Glad you posted such a great write up, Flux, as I've just started wondering about these lads. But, on first listen, I have to side with most of your reservations. This Raspberries pop sensibility re-tooled to take on Postal Service affection does not really leave me wanting more, but that does not mean I won't come back to it. It just doesn't smack of being accessible enough. For some reason, a voice in my head (is that Mojo Nixon??) screams "Vampire Weekend got no Elvis in them!!"
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  6. Marigold says Another great write up Colin. Jury is still out for me on VW. I like it alright, but I am not sure their tunes will last any longer then a vampire weekend on my Zune. (whatever a vampire weekend is)
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  7. FluxCapacitor says @ Tynansanger - Your Dad teaches in Columbia? Interesting. Well, if he did teach 'em, be sure to report back! @ myonlyappeal - Hey, thanks very much. I found it one of those albums where I find myself thinking that I can't wait to listen to again...as I'm listening to it. @ Kristiana - ...and off she goes into the night back to whence she came! Cheers, K! @ Scot - Thanks for your reply! I probably posted the most inaccessible song, lyrically-speaking. Still, I love it. I just find the chorus refrain very moving. If by Elvis, you mean soul, I think they have that in abundance. If you mean sex, they've got that too - although maybe some of the ladies who've heard the album could vouch for that better than I could!
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  8. FluxCapacitor says @ Mike - Heh thanks - whatever a Vampire Weekend is, it sounds intriguing and I think I'd like to have one!
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  9. HelenMarie says I've heard the album (raising hand) and I can vouch, sexually-speaking, they did do it for me but that was before I established images of Columbia University students in polo shirts...but really they don't appear totally prepped out... Regardless, I don't care much about sexual appeal...when listening to music...! I love their "Topsy-turvey world, pop" sound. Oxford Comma caught my attention with the feisty beginning "Who gives a fuck about an oxford comma" And Ladies of Cambridge is one of my favorites. Also have to say if one saw you beating on someone's chest while crying, “You brute! You brute!”...you may indeed be seen as "frivolous" or quite possibly "gay". *; )* (sorry for the large comment)
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  10. FluxCapacitor says Sunny, thanks for the large comment - the larger the better, right?! Great photo (and not stretched!) I like that one of them is wearing a nu-rave hoodie, hehe. I love Ladies of Cambridge, too - strange it was left off the album... as for the brute stuff... just conforming to the stereotype, or does that sound gay, too...ha!
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  11. AA Coppertop says "Of course, if anybody said so to my face, I wouldn’t hesitate to beat on their chest while crying, 'You brute! You brute!' And I hope that would be an end to the matter." is the line to beat on MOG this week. As for the music, if Ray Davies had fronted early Talking Heads, it might have sounded a little like this. Actually, these guys could just be the Strokes in a more restrained moment with a more restrained singer. Great essay, not bad band.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  12. Anna says Sorry, love, I can't agree with you on this one. I don't care about their class {or anybody's class, for that matter}, but their compositions sound to me like they're trying to cover too many things at once and fail, and, I will never be able to be at peace with those vocals. :( But hey, if it makes you sonically happy, I'm happy for that :)
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  13. FluxCapacitor says Hey AA - thanks! And you know it's funny, I had Ray Davies and Talking Heads in my notes but didn't use them in the end. Not in the way you suggested though - what a great imaginary band that would make.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  14. Cody B says I could see my son bopping to this, though he is quite wrapped up in a new video game. After listening to the record,I don't see why folks have their nose out of joint about their "African/world influences"..some claiming they aren't African enough. There really aren't that many influences! There's a little flavor, but not much. some reviewers bringing up King Sunny Ade..really? I liked the song you posted back in the day and I liked the album, but I liked your review better than both.. I felt the same way about people going gaga over the Talking Heads forays into world rhythms..I like the records,but I don't see the strong influence from African forms, 'cause it is so much filtered through the New Wave and personal sensibilities of the T.Heads. I think the same with the Vampires (so far anyway)..they may be influenced by King Sunny,but it is still them, and I can still dig it.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  15. FluxCapacitor says @ Anna - Okay. Now try listening without the bunny ears. ;)
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  16. FluxCapacitor says @ Cody - "I could see my son bopping to this, though he is quite wrapped up in a new video game." That's encouraging for their future (and typical!) The album is already much loved in our house (hard to please gf, too-cool-for school teen), even being put on during dinner time - the real test! "some claiming they aren't African enough" - That's absolutely comical, haha! Jesus, the arrogance and cluelessness of some people, assuming that they know better than the artist themselves about what they should or shouldn't be putting into their music - breathtaking! Guys like that need to take a long look at their lives...and perhaps go do something artistic themselves perhaps... And thanks for the kind words about my review - of course they wouldn't exist if I didn't love the music. So, here's to the Vampires and your son getting off the video games long enough to listen to 'em - I'm hopeful he'll like them when he does!
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  17. Bartleby says Gentle FluxC, thank you for your solicitude. As a matter of fact, I read your review hoping for culture (because these days it's hard to come by). And what did I find? This VW vinyl-killer My review of your review: high on pop but not much cultivation to deride from :p (Seriously, your impertinence is a delight) PS:
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  18. darmuzz says I was entirely on board with these guys until they started dissing commas.
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  19. zoraxx says I’m on my Fifth listen and it just keeps getting better. They Have A Wonderful Sound Very unique. And Yes Me And My young niece Can do with a bit of culture..:):)
    Permalink posted 01/30/2008
  20. FluxCapacitor says @ Michael - Thanks for brightening up the thread with your cultivated presence! Love your outside the box think(er)ing re VW. Excellento, my friend! @ Darla - ha ha! Weird story about that - My significant other is reading the punctuation book "Eats, Shoots and Leaves". On the day I got the Blue CD-R album demos, with her yet to hear any of it, she asked me what an Oxford Comma was... bizarre! @ Zoraxx - Now, that's what I'm talking about - the preppy look! Glad you're digging the album, yes the sound is very original, what with the mix of Afro-beats, orchestral music, and pop...very ambitious when you think about it....plus a talented wordsmith on top.
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  21. dermahrk says Perhaps they should take a cue from Joe Strummer and hide their middle-class background.It's the first thing of theirs I've heard and ..Marky likes it! Somehow that band name said "goth" to me, but your Shins & Simon reference led me to hit play and I discovered how wrong I was. Will have to check them out further.
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  22. FluxCapacitor says Strummer wasn't from the ghetto?? Say it ain't so! ;) Yeah, VW have decided not to hide anything, which I think is a brave decision... Athough it would be very difficult for them as their lyrics are full of references to people and places peculiar to their social status - like an upper-class Arctics, really. And good point on the name - absolutely sounds Goth. It could very well hurt them in the marketplace. I imagine indie bands think it's very cool to have an unconventional screw-the-system names...until they want to attract a bigger audience... and can't. (cf: Super Furry Animals!) Speaking of super furry animals, is Marky your new dog? He's beautiful. I saw your post during the week but didn't want any clumsy attempt at humour on my part to spoil the sweetness. Congrats on your new addition to the family!
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  23. dermahrk says Actually, Mark(y) is me and Mojo is the new pooch. I am already well into spoiling him rotten.
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  24. FluxCapacitor says Ha ha! Sorry! Hey Mark, I'm Colin! I'm glad you're spoiling him. A guy who works at a dog kennels once told me he loves to see people spoil their dogs because in his eyes it makes up for those dogs who aren't treated as well. Lucky Mojo!
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  25. Misstee says All of a sudden(well in the past 2 weeks) this is the only band i've been hearing about lately...
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  26. FluxCapacitor says "...yet your review spoke to me more than all the others combined, Fluxy dear." Aw, shucks, Misstee. That's so sweet. ;) PS. In the next two it'll be Hot Chip. You have been warned!
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  27. Misstee says i know(shockingly) about Hot Chip - Vampire Weekend was out of the blue...
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  28. FluxCapacitor says The "Blue CD-R":http://stereogum.com/archives/band-to-watch/band-to-watch-vampire-weekend_005100.html!
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  29. Charley Rogulewski says Prep rock. Over-hyped. These guys played a sold out show in NYC last night that the whole industry went to. My pal realized she didnt have tickets and started txting everyone in her Blackberry for an extra. I asked, "What are you doing? It's not like the end of the world if you dont go." I guess she likes a man who can sport a nice collar. These guys remind me of CYHSY, and the Little Ones. I am jonesing harder for MGMT. They don't sound like anything I've ever heard before http://www.myspace.com/mgmt
    Permalink posted 01/31/2008
  30. FluxCapacitor says HOUSE NOTICE: Since this is my living room on the net and not a public forum, I will delete all comments in future that 1) Make bigoted remarks towards poor innocent rich people 2) Recommend "better" bands whose albums I've already heard and dismissed as "kinda like touring mates, Yeasayer, only not as relatable or hairy". 3) Repeat every single Kewl Kid Kliche about the artists I review rather than lovingly quote said review, which I expect to have been read in its entirety, printed out, and memorized by heart. 4) Be somebody I don't know from Adam ("a news poster who seems human" Sturgell) 5) Do all of the above in one comment. (Impressive though that is.) Psyche! Only kidding! If I did, we'd miss out on the greatest thing about the web - flame wars! No, no, I mean...making friends. So, what I really want to say is... Hi Charley, I'm Colin! Pleased to meet ya!
    Permalink posted 02/01/2008
  31. Bartleby says What flame war? Did I miss anything? Cursed be me, I can't believe I'm late for some proper verbal scrap!!! (Colin I'll try to do all the above for your next review. Deal or no deal?)
    Permalink posted 02/03/2008
  32. FluxCapacitor says Deal! But be warned, I'll bring the big guns in reply. (i.e. I'll beat on your chest while crying, “You brute! You brute!”)
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  33. scotfree says Well, Brutus, told you I just might come back when the moon was full. VW played Letterman Fri - gotta say altogether different vibe than what I picked up earlier. Smacked not unlike early Elvis Costello, very tight, edgy, entertaining. Sign me up...
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  34. FluxCapacitor says Thanks for getting back. Interesting. Costello is a name I haven't heard in relation to them, but yes, I totally see it. Melodic and his music is intelligent and slyly humorous. I'm off to find the clip that changed your heart...
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  35. FluxCapacitor says Wow, they are fantastic live, such character and confidence. And they look great, which always helps. I like that they gave Letterman a vinyl copy to hold to camera - "Look at the size of this CD!"
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  36. fastnbulbous says
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  37. FluxCapacitor says Hey, thanks very much for the kind words. Yep, it's frustrating when a fine young band like VW are written off in a pithy phrase instead of being investigated properly. Many reviews just scratch the surface of what's going on in their songs. They look at the clothes or the fact they went to college...and that's it. That should be the starting point. Like, while listening the album and writing the review, I was surprised to find that many tracks were criticizing the society in which they grew up...while still being melodic - or, uh, "perky". Nobody talks about that.
    Permalink posted 02/04/2008
  38. ardyjormkiv says i appreciate your elequent and thorough review. having heard many mixed reviews (mostly giving no more than a 'yay' or 'nay'), i had decided for the most part to forego further attempts to listen to any more vampire weekend than i already have. you have caused me to rethink my actions...i am quite intrigued by the content.
    Permalink posted 02/05/2008
  39. FluxCapacitor says I'm surprised and delighted that my review encouraged you to have another listen. I hope you're rewarded. Thanks very much.
    Permalink posted 02/06/2008
  40. scotfree says Alright then, Mr. Flux, I'm back here one more time to try and put a period on this Oxford Comma. After the sixth listen today, I'm getting a bit concerned of future interests wane and pale. Thanks for cramming this into my brain so slyly, sometimes it takes an old dog a little longer...
    Permalink posted 02/19/2008
  41. scotfree says one more. pure magic. live in an outdoor courtyard in France, marvelous acoustics. These are def some talented lads. think this one deserves its own post...
    Permalink posted 02/19/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved