THE MUSIC BLOGGING HIVE MIND

Intro

Posted over 2 years ago
So I'm not really into social networking, or the so called 'blagging,' but I do love the music. And so I think I'll start things off by choosing one of the best covers of one of the best songs by one of the best solo artists: A Perfect Circle's rendition of John Lennon's Imagine.A band like A Perfect Circle (APC) really stands out in my mind because they're one of the few bands that understand a musical style so well to be able to take it to a new level. APC, at its core, is an emo band, but the difference between APC emo and other bands is their level of haunting guitars, and lyrical depth.Their Imagine cover (written by the truly wonderful John Lennon for those who decide to hate music) takes this song that was supposed to be uplifting by allowing the listener to 'imagine' what the world could be like, and completely changes the feel, tone, and meaning of the song with out changing the words.Maynard's minor toned vocals approach a mournful derdge that somehow exemplifies the sorry state of peace in the world. Paz Lenchantin's haunting violin almost reprises the Psycho murder music and takes the song from piano melody to a scary realization of how much time we don't have to change the world for the better. And underlying is a pulse from the piano that marches on into the inevitabilities of war.No other cover of John Lennon's perfect anti-war song brings to light the truth of how hard it is to live in peace in such a fashion as A Perfect Circle.EDIT: Ha ha, I had it that Paz Lenchantin played the guitar...

Comments (5)

  1. dermahrk says It's not bad, but they kept the lyrics and tempo only - totally new melody and chord changes. Not sure I'd call this a "cover", more of a re-imagining (?!?) of the song.
    Permalink posted 06/24/2007
  2. DasVerLemm says In all honesty, the term 'cover' is so loosely defined that somebody whistling the song would still be a cover. I like the term re-imagining and the way it fits, maybe i should have used that...
    Permalink posted 06/24/2007
  3. debi says Their version of Imagine is much more somber. Lennon's song has always been uplifting to me. I respect all artists though putting their take on a song. GREAT first post - welcome to Mog. Hope you'll keep posting your musical thoughts.
    Permalink posted 06/24/2007
  4. dermahrk says Yes, welcome. You'd be surprised how hooked you can get....
    Permalink posted 06/24/2007
  5. deadflowers says I've loved this version of Imagine ever since the first time I heard it (when I downloaded the album the week before it came out). I've since purchased it of course :)
    Permalink posted 07/10/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved