You say "Christian" like it's a bad thing... (Part 1)

Posted about 5 years ago
Note: This is not an indictment of ALL religious artists. I am simply pointing out a problem that I see in much of the Christian music community. Being a Christian myself, I am not making an attempt to disparage the religion.As a person who is more religious than most, I am a little bit frustrated with the Christian music scene these days. I have several reasons for this. In this post, I'd like to talk about the first of these reasons.It seems to me that one of the greatest failings of Christian music is in the area of song lyrics. Simply put, they are often a) Made up of repetitive phrases that sound like some sort of bizarre religious brainwashing, b) Guilty of recycling all of the images, icons, and lingo of the Christian faith and using them in a bland, unoriginal way, or c) Written almost as if the singer wants to have sex with Jesus (or a combination of a, b, and/or c).It is my belief that if the artists involved in Christian music were really intent on "bringing glory to God," they would be making music that would be well-crafted and worthy of the being they believe to be The Creator. Why don't we see this happening? Well, first of all, I think that many songwriters allow themselves to be limited by the accepted tropes of the genre, and simply don't innovate. Unfortunately, I believe a second reason is that God doesn't buy CDs, so why should anyone bother making something absolutely beautiful for Him?Do I think that all Christian musicians are sloppy writers or uninterested in pleasing God? No, it's almost certain that a lot of my problems with religious music stem from the fact that the writers and I have very different ideals as to what is beautiful, but this can't all be coincidence.If anyone else actually reads this, I'd love to hear your ideas on this subject.

Comments (1)

  1. Will to Imagine says In general, I agree with you. But at the same time, I have two favorite bands that are christian..however, this doesn't mean their music is christian. They might write the songs with their faith lending them inspiration or what-not, but often the actual song that comes out is much more open. Ok sure, there's often some underlying messages in the lyrics, but for me, I interpret them in a way that inspires me and is meaningful to me; me being one who is not christian. The two bands I refer to are Lifehouse and Switchfoot. Switchfoot has a series of motivational songs that are willing the listener to have some free will and to take control of their life and to make something of it all. This is a very open and beautiful philosophy that has no direct ties to religion. But if a band does decides to speak directly of religion, then their songs can either flow beautifully in honor to the one they believe in, or they can sound simply obsessive and blind as you mentioned. But a christian band can still sing with their faith behind them and yet produce music that can inspire everyone, even those who are not religious. It doesn't matter where the inspiration comes from if the music is beautiful and full of life. But all in all, when it comes to music from bands who happen to be christian, I'd still only recommend Lifehouse and Switchfoot.
    Permalink posted 02/29/2008

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved