THE MUSIC BLOGGING HIVE MIND

Bailey and Berlin take on Satan . . .

Posted about 1 year ago
  • Track:
    When That Man is Dead and Gone
Every veterans day, I listen to big band music. It never fails. So, I'll contribute to MOG by sharing "When that Man is Dead and Gone," done so beautifully by Mildred Bailey. How I love her. The first female vocalist to have a regular job with a dance band, her career was fostered by the likes of Bing Crosby, Paul Whiteman, Eddie Lang, Frankie Trumbauer, and Benny Goodman.What a sweet voice she had, and what a great juxtaposition it is against Irving Berlin's wry lyrics. Her smooth voice quips, "Satan, Satan, thought up a plan, dressed as a man, walkin' the Earth and since he began, the world is Hell for you and me, but what a Heaven it will be . . . when that man is dead and gone. . ."For you music theory heads, I'll just point out something so subtle and clever. This song is in a minor key, which, coupled with the swing-style upbeat tempo, makes it sound just a tad sneaky and menacing when the melody outlines a simple arpeggiation of the first chord. At 1:09, the chorus kicks in with the lyrics "we've got a date, to celebrate" and accompanying those lyrics is the relative major key. It sounds bright and optimistic, and even if you don't know music theory, on a subconscious level it's hard to miss that happy, but fleeting moment. Then, the very next line "the day we catch up with that one man spreadin' hate," we start to head back to a minor key, just to remind us that we are not really celebrating yet and that all is NOT well, (or perhaps that our mission is indeed NOT accomplished!) That harmonic twist, along with her great voice, the chorus and this agile clarinetist whose style just never ceases to make me grin is what makes this one of my favorite WWII era songs. The instrumentalists are unknown, but the vocalists are The Delta Rhythm Boys.Now, here's the best part. If you aren't aware of this, Irving Berlin is the very same man who wrote "God Bless America" and even better, this song was recorded in March 1941. America was not yet at war with Germany, but I sure do like that Berlin and Bailey and company weren't keeping their feelings a secret. I won't spoil the rest of the lyrics for you, but by now, I'm sure you've guessed our subject.I listened to this song every hour on the hour for 3 weeks after our current president was elected. I just needed some comfort. Oh, and 'I am', I chose this one for both your veteran status and your clarinet sensibilities. Enjoy and glad you are home safe.with affection and gratitude . . .

Comments (21)

  1. asrati says Yet another splendid post. Keep dropping the science.
    Permalink posted 11/11/2007
  2. Spike says I really enjoyed that. I like it when the verses are minor and the bridge is major. Going like that from a minor key to a major key can make you feel it open up. Years ago I saw a short film clip of her singing live probably from the late thirties or the forties, but it doesn't seem to be on YouTube. Speaking of our strong leader, you've got to admire his courage to risk losing the Jewish vote by not using namby-pamby Israeli interrogation methods on enemy combatants, but instead forging ahead on his own to get the needed false confessions.
    Permalink posted 11/11/2007
  3. Carolyn O'Brien says ha!! (goddamnit)
    Permalink posted 11/11/2007
  4. Dzendvokh says I agree, very informative (as usual) and again something I would not ordinarily run across in my daily listenings. I love your little theory classes BTW. Thanks C
    Permalink posted 11/11/2007
  5. Carolyn O'Brien says Aawww shucks and whew . . . I'm always worried I talk tooooo much. Who needs a knowitall pain in the ass? I'm just learning so much from all of you, I feel like I have to contribute in some way. I'm no historian and terrible with labels and all the other extramusical stuff, but I've gotta earn my keep some how.
    Permalink posted 11/11/2007
  6. Cody B says Tune is great.. Carolyn, sometimes I pine for the dark days of MOG, prior to the time when it was easy to post MP3's...It forced you to really explain yourself. Rap on is what I say... Nice one.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  7. Carolyn O'Brien says Oooooooh, dark MOG days? Was it dystopian? Did you fight MOG crime? In tights? A cape and mask? And, more importantly, did you get pictures?
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  8. Cody B says There were a lot of killers roaming the streets, as MOGwars rocked the board. "Dead Moggers everywhere":http://mog.com/Dale/blog_post/64325 But mostly there were a lot of youtube vids, very few MP3's to listen to, but quite a lot of good writing. Don't get me wrong, I love the MP3's, but I did like the more elaborate written posts as well.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  9. Dzendvokh says I wasn't around back then, but I think there is a pretty good mix of posts now. Personally I don't have the time to write a long write up every post, let alone read and respond to every post. I have lot's of ideas for longer posts and music I would like to investigate further, but I often feel like the music can speak for itself. I do always appreciate the time an energy put into interesting posts, not least among them, both of your's.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  10. Cody B says I ain't tryin' to say I don't like it the way it is now,dz. Among my trusteds, short ot=r long..quality is all that matters. I'm not complaining..any more than usual.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  11. Dzendvokh says I didn't take it that way Cody, I was just puttin my 2 cents in.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  12. Bartleby says Carolyn, dear. Shall I compare thee to a poppy...as Veteran Day is also know as Poppy Day for people in the UK? As usual your post is highly engrossing. Thanks to your pointing out the keys in which the tune are written, I was more sensitive to the song which I'd heard without noting the wry innnuendo. When I saw Bailey and Berlin I knew I'd be in excellent company. Mildred Bailey's got the sort of angelic voice which is just perfect for a rendez-vous with Satan. Reading your post, I'm in... Why not let Irving Berlin say it for me through Fred's dancing:
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  13. Carolyn O'Brien says *sigh* *swoon* *pant, pant* Smelling salts please? Bartleby, your mogging activity is the equivalent of Fred's moves. Clearly you are a triple threat.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  14. I am says Carolyn, I got a thing for big bands. My equation: Big Band = WW2 = Veterans = Fighting Boys = Rosie the Riveter = and somewhere in there Woody Allen (don't ask me why though). Thanks for the Milly B.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  15. Carolyn O'Brien says AAAAhhhh, I know exactly why you have Woody Allen in there. You probably don't need me to tell you. Yes, you are probably being sneaky and testing me, in fact, but he's a big clarinet boy. Yeah, you know this, don't you? His movie Radio Days is all about radio and WWII. Gotta see that about once a year just to warm my heart. Assuming you knew that already then tell me who croons this tune: "Get regular with relax (insert whistle here) Start of the day the relax way. Your system will feel so great you'll want to Relax on the top of the Empire State. . ."
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  16. I am says "Hawrk, The King approaches!" "Did You hear the lion rawr?" Sorry my Canarsie accent doesn't type well. Radio Days and Alice. 2 of my all time faves. I dig Shadow and Fog, but nobody else will watch it with me.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  17. Carolyn O'Brien says hahahaha, I was just wondering to myself how I was going to try to spell that. was it lions or cannons rawuhing? I thought it was cannons. hmmmm. . . as for nobody watching Shadows and Fog with you, these peeps are obviously bastards. solution: stop relaxing with bastards. (insert whistle here.)
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  18. I am says I think your right on both counts. You know I have yet to do an Allen post. How ever you might feel about him, You have to admit, he has a great ear and an ability to put the right music in the right scene.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  19. Carolyn O'Brien says Woody is brilliant. His musical aesthetic is perfect. Always. Even if I don't rate one of his films at the top of the heap vs. another, the scene and music is always always always perfect. Woody is as important and profound as ". . .sex and death. two things that come but once in a lifetime. . ."
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  20. missjunk says What a wonderful post. Such an amazing voice. Thank you for this.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  21. Carolyn O'Brien says You are most welcome, missjunk. I'm glad you liked it!
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved