WE DO THE MASHED POTATO AND THE FUNKY CHICKEN

Listening to Solitude

Posted over 2 years ago
Some books are familiar to us even though we have never read them. Such is "The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde." Then there are songs which resonate with us seemingly since time immemorial (to ourself.) Such is "Solitude."

But belief of knowledge is far from being bona fide knowledge. Does any one here really remember "a very odd story" connected with a door? Can any one really recall the muted trumpet introducing the strangely husky vocals?
We all know Lady Day with the magnolia in her hair. We have all seen her standing under the microphone, belting out. But look at the picture above. The simplicity of her robe, her hair flatly combed on her head, the wistful stare.
Billie Holiday's life too is perhaps all too familiar to us. We know of her luckless loves and hushed hearbreaks, of her heyday as well as her jail days, her glory and her fall out of grace. But listen now. Take some time to listen to her voice - powerful and powering - haunting you with a heartening vulnerability, an estranged and slow delivery - a kind of lazy shuffling. Just listen to her until you enter her intimate rhythm and hear her secret reveries.

Despite the weariness of time, despite the excess and abuse or perhaps because of it, the Lady from Baltimore has never sounded so touching and so moving.
Her "Solitude" is a solace to me.
(There is an informed review of this song by Bill Janovitz on allmusic.com)

Comments (17)

  1. Cody B says Story, no story, back story..whatever. You are so right, Billie almost always hits the spot.
    Permalink posted 10/27/2007
  2. 1234chainsaw says Nicely done and a good song choice from the Decca period. I just got the recently released 4CD Lady Day: The Master Takes and Singles box to fill my gaps in her Columbia period (that earlier 10CD complete box was always too big of a jump for me...). Having more Billie with Lester Young on sax never hurt.
    Permalink posted 10/27/2007
  3. dermahrk says Bartleby, I must confess that I have never "gotten" Billie Holiday. Somehow the tracks I heard (including of course the perhaps-overempasized "Strange Fruit") never really connected with me. This one is an exception. Loved it!
    Permalink posted 10/27/2007
  4. lilja88 says I loves it :)
    Permalink posted 10/27/2007
  5. FastRMacR says Pure taste. Blissful. Choice words. Exceptional tune. < shares solace > Thanks.
    Permalink posted 10/27/2007
  6. deadmandeadman says One rarely goes wrong with Billie. Your post is dynamite Sir Bartleby, for it brings Ms Holiday down to earth, places her in the difficult reality we all inhabit, and that makes her accomplishments all the more remarkable. As you say, we think we know her story, but few knew (or know) her roiled soul. We love her music, we honor her place in history, but maybe we forget the spirit sapping milieu in which she lived. Billie Holiday took the pain and frustration of her life and times and forged an incredible body of work that will be hailed forever. 1234Chainsaw, I've been contemplating the 4 cd Box set, how much of it is previously unreleased? dermahrk I've always suspected your music appreciation gene was damaged somehow, now I'm sure. How in hell can one NOT get Billie?
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  7. 1234chainsaw says Deadman: None of it is previously unreleased, as far as I know. It's culled from the 10CD box Lady Day: The Complete Billie Holiday on Columbia (1933-1944) that was released in 2001. I don't know if any further remastering has been done, but my guess would be No.
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  8. deadmandeadman says Thanks. I guess there's no need for me to buy it then. I own the 10 cd set.
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  9. Cody B says Can't complain about the music on that 10 CD box, but Oy Vey! the design is not user friendly, if you want to actually listen to the CD's.
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  10. deadmandeadman says Yeah, I agree, I was gonna mention something to that effect but.......
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  11. soulrocket says i am more familiar with her blues years, but i am loving this "crooner" side of her.. of course it should be released by decca. great post as usual, B.
    Permalink posted 10/28/2007
  12. Carolyn O'Brien says Ooooh, yes please. Just like your post of Jimmy Scott, I also like the older voice of Billie. I put this song right up there with Autumn in New York and Gloomy Sunday. I actually really love Strange Fruit, too, though. There is a book about the history of that song. You probably already know it, but just in case it's called "Strange Fruit, The Biography of a Song," by Dave Margolick. The song has a controversial and interesting history, but I have a feeling my even just mentioning it to you is redundant. Thank you so much for you beautiful page. I know I'll visit often.
    Permalink posted 10/31/2007
  13. Bartleby says My apologies for not responding to your incredible comments earlier. Carolyn recalled me to host’s duties. My dear friends and excellent visitors, the aim of this post was indeed a review of our so-called familiarity with such and such pieces of art, be it literature or music. There are many versions of “Solitude.” But for me, none have reached the pregnant poignancy of Billie Holiday’s rendition. I’m just glad I could share this with you. Cody: Billie is a true marks-woman ;) 1234C: Indeed, a bit Lady Day and the Prez never hurts. I’ve been desperate to find a particular recording of hers ever since I read “The Invention of Solitude” – something from 1941. It’s been so long now I can’t seem to remember what it is any more. Dermahrk: I know what you mean. Some artists are supposed to be “unmissable” but they are not meant to be liked by everyone. Still, I’m glad you’ve found something likable in Billie. Lilja: Many thanks for popping around this side of MOG. Glad you enjoyed it. FastR: It's true honour to have you in this MOG-abode. I'm glad you found Billie heartening. DMDM: Thank you for your insightful comment. Some artists do seem to be living their work, don't they? Soulrocket: Decca does indeed a wonder job researching materials and sprucing them up for re-issues. Thanks for popping around. Carolyn: Your comments are not redundant at all. As a matter of fact, I’ve only read a review on Margolick’s book. That shows you how superficial I am. It is I who should thank for your presence in this MOG -closet.
    Permalink posted 10/31/2007
  14. FastRMacR says (blush) Thanks for that comment. The feeling is mutual. Your musical tastes here are most assuredly some of the finest listening in the sphere. Notwithstanding, the choice of your named presence bespeaks volumes. I studied The Literature so much 10 years ago that I denied _reading_ all but the comics - literally - after the degree. Commenting about Billy Holiday with a cat named 'Bartleby' is just the greatest thing! You have compelled me to .. read up again (and keep my verbosity at a minimum). I thank you for setting such a great caliber and par here - sincerely. So I came back here to listen to this great cut only to be daunted by a little 30-second 'yellow' button. I'm also _very curious_ about "something from 1941". Prithee another clue? MOG _is_ about finding, non?
    Permalink posted 12/16/2007
  15. Bartleby says Well, this is the straw that breaks... I don't know what happened. It looks as though Rhapsody has blog-jacked my post and music. It should have been something like this:

    MOG 2.0 and Rhapsody thought it better to take full ownership of the mp3 file I'd uploaded because it was on their catalogue. I've read about it but didn't see with my eyes. Thank you for alerting me to this. PS: Luckily by editing the original post one can still retrieve the mp3 upload and re-attach to the post or comments.
    Permalink posted 12/16/2007
  16. FastRMacR says Now THAT hit the spot. Many thanks for the listen. "You so gallantly charge the foe, thus!" Nice touch with the retro player. Great artists steal and they _steal this book_:/ You know, a man like Ellington with this song is a nice moment too. Best O the wintry Merry crimble to you! Cheers!


    Permalink posted 12/16/2007
  17. Bartleby says Thanks FastR - I was familiar with Duke's original but this a case of the borrower bests the borrowed.
    Permalink posted 12/16/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2009 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved