What Happened To Smith?

Posted over 4 years ago
I've never been a member of the cult of Brooklyn. It's nothing personal, it's just that I've never lived there. I have friends who swear by it. I've had friends flee Manhattan to Brooklyn's (slightly) less expensive environs, and now smack their foreheads wondering why they didn't to it sooner. They love Brooklyn. Hey, that's cool. Brooklyn's alright with me, although any time I see one of those "Defend Brooklyn" t-shirts - invariably on some chinless Williamsburg hipster with ironic hair - I want to douse them in gasoline and strike a match. But otherwise, yeah - Brooklyn's great.

I spend much of my time on my weblog bitterly lamenting the tireless gentrification of my borough, Manhattan, although not quite as bitterly as the endearingly irritable Jeremiah Moss of Vanishing New York, whose posts are filled with deliciously palpable vitriol for the condo kids, the "yunnies" and the vacuous "Sex And The City" obsessives who are gradually sucking the character and lifeblood out of our beloved island. I discovered Moss' website a couple of months ago, and now welcome each new post of his, and shake my fist along with him.

But it's not just the cultural and historic fabric of downtown Manhattan that's slowly disappearing, it's the entire city. Doubtlessly inspired by Lynn Ermann's article about the Upper East Side from the New York Times, I took my little daughter uptown yesterday to check out one of my old neighborhoods, Yorkville. Huge swathes of East 86th Street have been razed to accommodate a clutch of new, homogenous and monolithic condominiums. Many of the age-old businesses I remember from my childhood are long gone, replaced by Starbucks, Barnes & Nobles and the like. With all the frontiers discovered, pillaged and exhausted, it seems like only a matter of time before New York City effectively eats itself.

At this point, I going to write a detailed account of the best song about the gentrification of New York City I've yet encountered. It's titled "What Happened to Smith?", and It's by one of my favorite local bands (I've written about them here before), Life in a Blender. But I see that an equally grizzled gentrification-loathing Brooklynite has beaten me to it. Whatever your borough, the lyrics speak volumes about the current trajectory of the city.

Sale on the dairy in the circular by my feetIf I keep my eyes downward, it’s the same old streetThen there’s the unlettered awning and the one blue lightAnd the trance like music and the crowd’s all whiteThere’s a clap of goateesSomeone’s smoking a spliffIt’s 90 percent ManhattanMan what Happened to Smith?What Happened to Smith? (x4)All the social clubs are pulling down their shadesThe old gang on Sackett’s closing up their bladesWhere’s the five dollar hero? It’s just $20 and tip.You might as well starve tonightOh man, what happened to Smith?Forget about rent, don’t’ think about rent, it’s already spentJust try to pull through, pass the well-to-doDressed down in their thrift clothesStill you’ll see the clues all the girls balancedin their Manolo Blahnik shoesYellow tinted glasses exposed mid driftOh man What Happened to Smith?Some TV cop show producer wants me to move my automobileWell up your ass I think my cellular phone you should concealI’ll wait it out by the Gowanus. I’ll wait for the scene to shiftI’ll take the stench of the canalOver what happened to Smith

Play it loud and punch out a real estate developer.

Comments (4)

  1. Sturgell says I moved to BK when I was about 17 from California with 200 bucks in my pocket, less than a month before the disaster. By the grace of god did I make it and not have to mug people. I had a three bedroom place I only paid $850 a month for. Brooklyn is a wonderful place, but gosh darn it, it's a hell of a place to struggle when your just a kid. Anyways, it's dumpy place with a lot of charm. great post! very insightful for a guy who's never been.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  2. Alex in NYC says I never said I've never been to Brooklyn. I've just never lived there.
    Permalink posted 11/12/2007
  3. missjunk says Have you been to Chicago? Same thing. Whole neighborhoods, gone. Little bakeries, little taverns, family run restaurants pushed out because the rent got to high, little storefronts... all gone gone gone. Replaced by these ugly, communist looking condo boxes. The whole city of Chicago has been transformed from neighborhoody, friendly to bananarepublic/starbucks/gap/barnes&noble/subway. Same sad choices on the next block. And the next. I was in New York recently and went to an old neighborhood Pizza place, just outside of Greenich Village, this little mom and pop place had been in the same neighborhood for years. The owner told me it was going to be his last year, his rent had gone from (get ready to gasp) $11,000 a month to $21,000 a month. He said, that he was now in a prime real estate area, highly desired and that at $21,000 a month, "thats a hell-of-alot of pizza" he now couldn't make it. I have found, that cities such as Milwaukee, Baltimore, Cleveland, Detroit & Philadelphia, old old old working class cities, still have the old flavors, the old neighborhoods, and have been mostly left untouched by the the 1990's new urbanism. (ie tear it down and put an ugly condo there-pack em in-make money) These cities are NOT New York or Chicago, but at least they seemed to have survived, where the big dogs, sort of lost there souls.
    Permalink posted 11/13/2007
  4. Cody B says Excellent post. My wife lived in Manhattan (upper West) in the 70's and she's always shocked by the changes. she knows that someone in her position then (student) could never afford to live the way she did then (with roommates,but in a huge place that would prolly be 3 or 4 appartments now or condos) I live in a "less hot" aw hell, cold neighborhood, Bay Ridge. I think if you are far enough on the train from Manhattan you are relatively safe from gentrification. If you don't have to go in much (me), that works just fine. "I wrote this about Williamsburg and some other things in '02":http://mog.com/Cody_B/blog_post/71996
    Permalink posted 11/13/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved