Major threat to "Walk Away"

Posted almost 5 years ago
I'm going to vent a little - but only a little, and on an anal point that most of you won't give a flying fuck about. Franz Ferdinand's sophomore record You Could Have It So Much Better was largely a letdown - really, a caricature of the sound of their debut album and their copious influences. But it has a few stellar tunes that continue to hit me with the force of a sledgehammer every time I hear them. (We could have had it so much better, indeed!) The jangly "Walk Away" is one of these, and it's a song I enjoy playing on a guitar myself. The chords are easy enough to figure out, but the other day I set out to find tabs for the song on the web, because I wanted to confirm what a couple of the notes in the guitar solo are. I did discover what those notes are, but I was astonished to find out that every bloody tab I came across was wrong on one crucial point. They all had the chord for that "Don't you walk away" line in the chorus that follows "The sun won't swallow the sky" (in 1st chorus) and "The Kremlin's falling" (in 2nd chorus) as G major (or F, if you have a capo on the 2nd fret). But it's absolutely crucial to the song that it be G minor (or Fm, if you have a capo). It's not a happy song, for goodness' sake! See for yourselves:The official video for the song is pretty deliciously noir, but if I posted that here, people might think that in my view the video should not be re-shot with a certain mogger as the female lead, and that kind of mog-ire I would fear to provoke.

Comments (9)

  1. marramarie says I am love Franz, and I was not as happy with the 2nd album as the first. I think it was due to the labels or powers that be that they get an album out as quickly as possible. I am sure that was alot to deal with them coming from. Alex is not your typical singer/songwriter, and I am sure he feels he could have with a little more time, had a better album. I can't wait for the new one to come out!
    Permalink posted 03/03/2007
  2. Rawkkiddoh says I agree about the second album. The first did a lot more for me than the second, and while I do not play guitar, the first album had me wishing I did a lot more.
    Permalink posted 03/03/2007
  3. Jonh Ingham says On the plus side, they write some of the best lyrics around.
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  4. Anna says You're so lucky that I like you...
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  5. 1234chainsaw says Eek, Anna, I said there was great stuff on the record! In addition to "Walk Away," at least "Fade Together" and "Eleanor Put Your Boots On." It's just that much of the rest is Franz-lite. Anyway, I was hoping that my last sentence would distract you enough to help me get away with some critical remarks...
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  6. Anna says ............. Fade Together and Eleanor are the songs I like the least. .............. I don't get distracted easily...but that doesn't mean that I didn't enjoy your last sentence ;)
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  7. 1234chainsaw says Hmm, I think those songs save the album from being completely predictable and derivative from their first, especially the Beatles-y feel of "Eleanor". I do enjoy "This Boy" and "You're the Reason I'm Leaving" but frankly I feel that much of the rest isn't particularly memorable even if it is energetic in the moment and the lyrics are witty (Jonh's right about that).
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  8. Anna says You're an Evil and a Heathen.
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007
  9. 1234chainsaw says Happy to oblige. As for distraction, I guess I'll have to be more devious in the future ;o)
    Permalink posted 03/04/2007

Comment on this Post

Login using email and password below.

Forgot Password?

OR login using Facebook Connect

Connect

Don't have an account?
Join MOG. It's Free!

© 2006-2012 Mog Inc. All Rights Reserved